Ireland player ratings V Germany

Who played best for Ireland? Miguel Delaney rates the team

Ireland player ratings V Germany

Shay Given 6

Off early, but it was more through misfortune rather than exertion. It is remarkable that, in a 42-minute spell in which Germany almost totally dominated and had several shots, Given didn’t really need to extend himself. He didn’t have a single save to make.

Cyrus Christie 8

The biggest game of his career so far but superbly kept his head, and more often than not kept Germany at bay. Had one worrying moment with Mario Goetze in the first half and then Andre Schurrle in the second, but it showed his composure that none of that affected him.

Richard Keogh 8

Has never completely inspired confidence for Ireland, but this was a creditably assured and complete display - especially given the quality of the opposition. Performed one brilliant interception in the first half, and continued in that vein.

John O’Shea 8

Even if he’s not the player he used to be, most of the team like him there for his leadership, and he led by example here - especially with a brilliant block on Ilkay Gundogan.

Stephen Ward 7

A surprise selection given that he hasn’t played a single minute in the Championship for Burnley, but kept focus here. Never a wrong step.

Robbie Brady 8

If it’s now unusual to see him as a winger for Ireland, this match ensured he was effectively a secondary full-back. Again showed he has accustomed superbly. Did well to oust Thomas Muller on 12 minutes, and got better the further he had to go back.

James McCarthy 9

One of his best games for Ireland, in which he rarely put a foot wrong. That probably has a lot to do with the fact he wasn’t this time expected to play the kind of more assured and commanding passes that are usually missing from his game with Ireland, however. Instead, this was all about getting amongst the Germans and tackling. He did that superbly, most notably with a fine interception to deny Marco Reus on the half-hour.

Jeff Hendrick 7

Was never going to be able to offer the kind of innovation he did in the Georgia game, instead showing so much industry.

Wes Hoolahan 9

A technical level above every Irish player, and with the composure to match. It was difficult to keep up with the amount of times he calmed things down and alleviated the pressure - both on the Irish box and Irish minds - by taking control with the right pass, although there was one moment when that casualness led to a German attack. Otherwise, excellent, with an exquisite drag-back to match.

Jon Walters 7

The perfect forward player for this kind of game, given his defensive work and willingness to hustle. Might have had a penalty in the first half, and came close with a scuffed shot after a good link-up with Hoolahan.

Daryl Murphy 7

An utterly thankless kind of game for a striker. It said much that, as the furthest man forward, he didn’t even get to be isolated on the half-way line. He was often back near the Irish box, especially for corners, although did well to clear one.

Darron Randolph 9

Quite an introduction to competitive international football, and quite a step-up. Pulled off two supreme saves.

Shane Long 9

After an amazing finish like that, it’s all the more amazing that he didn’t start.

David Meyler 7

Adjusted to the battle well.

x

More in this section

Sport

Newsletter

Latest news from the world of sport, along with the best in opinion from our outstanding team of sports writers. and reporters

Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Brand Safety FAQ Help Contact Us Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited