South Africa media critical of Boks as 'one-dimensional' and 'losing their aura' after Ireland defeat

'Hubris is the word that comes to mind. The Boks can blame the officials all they want, but in their last four games they have beaten only Italy'
STRAIN: South Africa's Lood de Jager and Ireland's James Ryan during a maul in their Nations Championship clash at the Aviva Stadium. Pic: Nick Elliott, Inpho

STRAIN: South Africa's Lood de Jager and Ireland's James Ryan during a maul in their Nations Championship clash at the Aviva Stadium. Pic: Nick Elliott, Inpho

“THE Springboks bomb again,” screamed the headline in the Afrikaans language Rapport website after the world champions slumped to a 20-17 loss to Ireland at the Aviva.

“Ireland inflict fourth defeat of the season on one-dimensional Springboks,” said the headline of the county’s largest independent news site Daily Maverick.

“Springboks stumble into Nations Championship final but warning bells are ringing,” was the headline in IOL.co.za. “Bombarded by their floundering under their own high balls. Knocked out by their own inadequate exit plans. Shot in the foot by their own poor discipline. And now stripped of their aura of invincibility, the Springboks are on the back foot,” Rapport’s Hendrik Cronje wrote.

“Hubris is the word that comes to mind,” said Daily Maverick’s Craig Ray.

“The Boks can blame the officials all they want, but if they do an honest assessment of themselves, defeats to Australia, France and now Ireland are not because of poor officiating. In their last four games they have beaten only Italy,” Daily Maverick continued.

“It feels like the world champions have regressed in recent months and they have become increasingly one-dimensional. They scrum and they hoof the ball into the air and try to win that way. It’s predictable – but more worryingly – it’s increasingly ineffective.

“Teams that stand up to them in the set pieces tend to come out on top. The Boks look slow and old. Their attacking development of 2025 seems to have been parked indefinitely. The evolution under attack coach Tony Brown is a distant memory. They’re playing more like the Boks of 2016.” 

The Independent on its IOL website was also critical.

“Springbok fans would have been unsure whether to laugh or cry at the final whistle in Dublin on Saturday night after losing 20-17 to Ireland, yet advancing to the final of the inaugural Nations Championship,” IOL’s Mike Greenaway said.

“The Springboks have finished top of the Southern Hemisphere log to move past New Zealand, but if they hope to win the trophy next week at Twickenham, they need to find the mojo that has gone missing in the last fortnight in Europe.” Timeslive’s Mark Keohane also did not gloss over the Boks’ shortcomings.

“These world champion Boks don’t play for losing bonus points, but they were made to look secondary during a pulsating first half,” Keohane wrote.

“The Boks were just as poor when trying to win the game in the final few minutes. They had field position and possession, but they lacked the patience and execution to close out a game they never looked like winning.

“Ireland, who scored three tries in the first half to the Springboks’ one, were comfortably the better all-round team.” The Citizen’s Jacques van der Westhuizen wrote: “In an arm-wrestle of a game, watched by banned coach Rassie Erasmus from the team hotel, Ireland were the better team in most areas against an error-ridden Bok side.” 

While much of the coverage centred on the match and the growing sense that the Springboks are becoming more predictable and stolid rather than expanding their repertoire, there were also some references to absent coach Rassie Erasmus.

Banned for six matches after suggesting the possibility of “match-fixing” in their 21-19 loss to France on 13 November, Erasmus hosted a “watch party” from his Dublin hotel.

South Africa's Kurt-Lee Arendse tackles Ireland's Hugo Keenan. Pic: Nick Elliott
South Africa's Kurt-Lee Arendse tackles Ireland's Hugo Keenan. Pic: Nick Elliott

Just what it achieved is unclear. Apparently, the viewership peaked at about 900,000 at one stage. Watching Erasmus drink brandy and colas and stare at a screen, interspersed with him talking animatedly to someone, was hardly riveting viewing.

There were suspicions he was communicating with the Springbok technical team at the Aviva, but that has been denied.

Erasmus gave his own verdict on the first half to fans, although he did not engage after the final whistle.

“Obviously not 100% happy, Ireland have got most of the possession and territory,” Erasmus said to his viewers at halftime.

“I think most of the kicking game, if they didn’t catch it cleanly, they won the scraps for the ball.

“We did prep for that (Ronan Kelleher’s try). “We call it a front peel, where it’s a dummy maul in the front. I think if Canan (Moodie) was a little bit more up, that could have been stopped.

“Then obviously, if you give a stupid penalty away, being in front of the kicker after you scored, you give them a 22-metre entry and then they normally kill you. So yes, we’ve not been playing perfect. In one way, that’s great news because if we step it up, I think we’ll be in this match.

“Ireland have been really clinical, but I would be much more worried if we played perfectly, and we’re not currently playing perfectly.

“We shouldn’t just play to get one bonus point or be within seven or only score four tries. And I think the chat at half-time – I’m not there, but it would be, ‘Listen, let’s try and beat these guys, not get a bonus point out of it. Thanks again, guys. Keep on supporting. Thank you.”

More in this section

Sport

Newsletter

Sign up to our daily sports bulletin, delivered straight to your inbox at 5pm. Subscribers also receive an exclusive email from our sports desk editors every Friday evening looking forward to the weekend's sporting action.

Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Brand Safety FAQ Help Contact Us Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited