'Keep 15 on the pitch': Simon Easterby warns Ireland ahead of South Africa clash

Sam Prendergast’s citing and a growing injury list complicate Ireland’s preparations for their Nations Championship clash with South Africa
Discipline issues cost Ireland dearly in the 2025 clash with South Africa. Pic: ©INPHO/Gary Carr

Discipline issues cost Ireland dearly in the 2025 clash with South Africa. Pic: ©INPHO/Gary Carr

Simon Easterby had just highlighted the importance of discipline ahead of Ireland’s meeting with the Springboks next weekend when it was reported that Sam Prendergast was to be cited for a hip-drop tackle made against Fiji two days earlier.

It made for a bad start to a week that needs to go well for Andy Farrell’s side given they have lost all of their last six games against the world’s best three teams by double-digit margins, and with last year’s Bok beating still fresh in the mind.

Prendergast was one of five players shown a yellow card 12 months ago when they lost 24-13. James Ryan’s was upgraded to a 20-minute red and both Andrew Porter and Paddy McCarthy spent ten minutes in the bin for their part in the setpiece sundering.

Ireland found themselves down to 12 men at one point in that 2025 encounter so Easterby, the team’s defence coach, had a succinct message when asked what the key would be when facing South Africa this time around.

“Trying to keep 15 on the pitch would be helpful. Making sure you are as disciplined as you can be, not to give them access points. Physically, you've got to match them, if not better than better that. You know it's easier said than done.

“But we've shown in the past when we have been a match for them and better than them, we've delivered a physical performance both sides of the ball that has stopped them getting the type of momentum that, when they do get it, they're a difficult team to play against.” 

Easterby built on that point by stressing how discipline isn’t just a case of someone not tapping the ball out of a ruck with their hands. Discipline, he said, is about how a team prepares through the week too.

It was ironic, then, that a moment of indiscipline from the weekend before could threaten the team’s hopes – even if Rassie Erasmus thinks otherwise - given Prendergast’s importance as the team’s starting No.10 right now.

The hip-drop tackle has been banned officially since the start of this current Test window. As in other sports, player safety is at the crux of it and Prendergast seems to have fallen foul of one such attempt on Peceli Yato during the first-half on Saturday.

Yato left the field shortly after scoring his try moments later.

If the Leinster playmaker was to be unavailable then Ciarán Frawley of Connacht would be next man up. The Skerries clubman has come off the bench in the games against Argentina and Fiji. Munster’s Jack Crowley is out injured since late last season.

Jamie Benson is next in line at the out-half position. A versatile player who can play in numerous positions around the backline, he is uncapped at Test level. This is fraught stuff for Ireland on this of all weeks.

The No.8 position had already been giving cause for concern what with Caelan Doris, Jack Conan, Sean Jansen and now James McNabney, after his short cameo on debut against Fiji was cut short by a head knock, are all unavailable.

Dan Sheehan, who started there for Leinster against Munster last month, is taking part in training after he missed the Fiji tie with a head injury of his own. Jamie Osborne is out with a pec problem and Sam Illo is a maybe after his head knock at the weekend.

Illo has been back-up to Tadhg Furlong at tighthead so far this window. Thomas Clarkson is the next cab on that rank but he hasn’t featured once in November. Another cause for concern given the focus on the setpiece this week.

France showed on Friday that the ‘no scrum, no win’ cliché doesn’t always ring true but it’s no blueprint for an Irish team that was embarrassed in that department 12 months ago. The flip side is that the memory of it, the fear of a repeat, should act as some fuel.

“We've moved on, they will have moved on as well from that,” said Easterby.

“We need to make sure that we're better in lots of areas, but making sure we're disciplined and avoiding the avoidable penalties and avoiding the opportunities that we give them access to will go a long way for us to be in the fight in the end.”

More in this section

Sport

Newsletter

Sign up to our daily sports bulletin, delivered straight to your inbox at 5pm. Subscribers also receive an exclusive email from our sports desk editors every Friday evening looking forward to the weekend's sporting action.

Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Brand Safety FAQ Help Contact Us Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited