Final Demand battles back to win thrilling John Durkan Memorial Punchestown Chase
Final Demand and Patrick Mullins (left) win from Fact To File and Gaelic Warrior for trainer Willie Mullins. Pic: Healy Racing
A Grade 1-winning novice last season, Final Demand dug deep to foil Fact To File in another thrilling renewal of the John Durkan Memorial Punchestown Chase.
In the news in recent weeks, having been disqualified from second place in the ‘Brown Advisory’ at Cheltenham in March, the seven-year-old was headed on the run-in but battled bravely under strong driving from Patrick Mullins, to foil the Harry Cobden-ridden Fact To File by a neck, with Gold Cup victor Gaelic Warrior almost four lengths back in third in a €150,000 contest for which all nine runners were trained by Willie Mullins.
“It was a fantastic race and a great result for the Mullins family, not just Closutton - a Grade 1 winner for Patrick and seeing him outride Harry Cobden from the last home,” stated the winning trainer. “Patrick said he thought he had the race won when he missed the last but he fought back to win it a second time.
“This was Final Demand’s first day at big boys’ school, so it was a very good performance, a huge result for a second season novice. It’s very promising going forward.
“He was good all the way around, against those top-class horses. This show how much he has improved from last year.
“I thought all the horses ran well, although I was a little disappointed with Impaire Et Passe. Kitzbuhel enjoyed himself and ran very well and I thought Kaid D’authie ran a cracker. Paul was happy with Gaelic Warrior and said he’d be happy to take them on again over three miles.”
Final Demand is owned by Dr Caroline Tisdall and Bryan Dreew, who commented: “I’m elated, on cloud nine. We hoped that he’d run well and be in the top three, giving us hope for the season. But this but is amazing. It proves that he’s a genuine Grade 1 horse. He’s the best horse I’ve ever owned, a horse with the X-factor.
And Rich Ricci, owner of Gaelic Warrior, added, “Paul said he blew up a couple of times and got boxed-in but got outpaced. But he was very positive and said he wouldn’t swap him.”
Willie Mullins, who registered trebles at Punchestown on both Saturday and yesterday, now faces the task of making plans for all nine charges who contested yesterday’s race, with the ‘Savills’ at Leopardstown and the ‘King George’ at Kempton likely targets for many of them.
For Fact To File, winner of the race in 2024, it was a second defeat by a neck in the ‘Durkan, having failed narrowly to Gaelic Warrior in the race twelve months ago.
Earlier, Ocastle Des Mottes, in the familiar Munir/Souede colours, sparked the Mullins treble completed a chasing hat-trick when putting his experience to good use in the Grade 2 Matchbook Betting Exchange Craddockstown Novice Chase.
Previously successful at Galway and Listowel, the seven-year-old made all found plenty in the closing stages to beat the Colm Murphy-trained pair, chasing debutante Zanoosh and eye-catcher Lovely Hurling.
“I thought Paul was fantastic on him – he gave him a super ride and the horse responded,” declared Mullins, “He’s a second season novice and we played to our strengths, his fitness and experience.”
And, out of luck with Gaelic Warrior, owners Rich and Susannah Ricci saw their Caesar’s Ball, a point-to-point winner for Sam Curling, produced an impressive performance in the Keadeen Hotel Pro-Am Flat Race, second leg of a double for Patrick Mullins and a sixth winner of the weekend for his trainer.
Rising star Dan King completed a fine 50/1 double, highlighted by the gutsy victory of Dick Donohoe’s grey mare Daboya in the listed Frontline Security Grabel Mares Hurdle. The 5/1 shot mastered flattering odds-on favourite Oldschool Outlaw on the run-in before holding Ill Raise A Glass by a half-length.
King was successful earlier when guiding 15/2 shot Maxford, trained for owner/breeder Tom Egan by Nicky Stokes, to a smooth success over World As One in the Colm Quinn BMW Novice Handicap Hurdle. In double form in Cork, Gordon Elliott also won the Irish Stallion Farms EBF maiden Hurdle with the Jack Kennedy-ridden 11/10 favourite Theflyingking.
The Ian McCarthy-trained Fountain House, ridden by Eoin Mahon, retained his unbeaten record at Punchestown and registered his third win over the track’s cross-country track when landing the Donohue Marquees Risk Of Thunder Chase.
The eight-year-old will head for Cheltenham for a cross-country event in January before returning to the Punchestown festival, where he doubled-up last spring.




