John Fallon: Trust in FAI undermined by safeguarding debacle

Safeguarding gaps and the standing down of thousands of coaches and referees have left the FAI facing urgent questions about oversight, accountability and trust
Sport Ireland doesn't feel this fiasco reached the threshold for threatening funding. Pic: Seb Daly/Sportsfile

Sport Ireland doesn't feel this fiasco reached the threshold for threatening funding. Pic: Seb Daly/Sportsfile

Once the glamour of a Euro draw on home soil and the women’s World Cup playoff subsides, there’s a larger chestnut for the FAI to digest approaching Christmas.

Whether safeguarding is a new or old chestnut, it is imperative in the context of its breadth across the game and the seriousness of neglect.

This relates to adults working with minors and vulnerable persons possessing the correct and current clearances.

They’re two-fold, one related to Garda vetting and the second a safeguarding training course provided by the governing body.

Right now, the problem for the FAI is that their biggest funder, the Government, are not convinced the body is on top of this subject.

The Joint Oireachtas committee on sport expressed collective concern during a sitting last Wednesday. That the FAI refused to attend the hearing only compounded their anger.

When the association did attend on September 30, assurance was provided by chief executive David Courell they were at the “front of the pack with regard to this (safeguarding)”.

So much has gone on since the visit that one of the committee members, Peter ‘Chap’ Cleere, was minded to provide a summary. “Everything was hunky dory five weeks ago but now the FAI are waiting on an independent investigator’s review,” he said.

Let’s take a breather to recap. On foot of the FAI’s inability to provide answers to basic questions around safeguarding compliance levels across coaches and referees, follow-on information was promised.

It soon emerged that in the course of searching for those answers, the FAI encountered problems. Major problems.

Within a week of their trip to Government buildings, an emergency meeting of their board was called to reveal the centralised system they use for tracking, FAI Connect, was beset by gaps.

It transpires that Sport Ireland chief executive, Dr Úna May, was contacted by ‘phone’ immediately after the meeting flagging the ‘significant issues’.

Within an hour of the Irish Examiner reporting that thousands of coaches would be stood down, an FAI statement confirmed that ‘inconsistencies’ had been uncovered.

All affected coaches, volunteers and referees received an email at 11pm that night – following the FAI Cup semi-final between Bohemians and Waterford – reminding them to have their compliance documentation in order.

That’s good and well but what this debacle has exposed is a glaring absence of oversight.

Last week’s follow-up sitting, attended by Sport Ireland, the department of sport, the Garda National Vetting Bureau but not the FAI, heard details that the sense of panic has continued.

For instance, after four meetings between Sport Ireland and the FAI since they were first alerted, the state agency is still unsure of whether any athletes were put at risk arising from these shortcomings.

The FAI had also met with the vetting bureau and written to Tusla, the child and family agency, seeking guidance on the application of vetting procedures.

They also repeated what they’ve done in previous crises to buy some time – commission an independent review. That is being conducted by Safe Sport International and is due to be completed by the end of November.

Clashes with international fixtures were cited as the excuse for the FAI delaying their appearance until December but when they do in the coming weeks clear and concise findings will be expected as to how and why football has got itself into the pickle of having 6000 coaches and referees deactivated from the system.

One of the main takeaways, no doubt, will be the dysfunction attached to the largest league in the country by far, the 50,000 player Dublin District Schoolboys’/girls league, not being part of a Connect system heretofore presented as robust and fit for purpose.

There was also the bizarre case highlighted by senator Evanne Ní Chuilinn of one league, the Leinster Senior, issuing a standalone matchday sheet to clubs for the listing of personnel not on the Connect system. There’s a lot of dots seemingly disconnected.

It was evident from the vetting bureau’s input that an avalanche of applications had occurred since this matter entered the public domain, but they were adamant these would be processed within 10-13 working days.

If the scrambling achieves a dividend, there’ll be something substantive for the FAI to report on their belated appearance but the damage around trust and culture will be too late to retrieve.

Sport Ireland doesn't feel this fiasco reached the threshold for threatening funding – as it did in 2025 when the holiday pay scandal of chief executive Jonathan Hill arose – but May’s derision was apparent when she eventually stopped deferring questions to the FAI.

“I have a frustration around the fact that there’s more issues than anticipated,” she said.

Festive cheer from the FAI's overlords will be in short supply regardless of how much progress is made on the pitch.

Email: john.fallon@examiner.ie

Adam O'Reilly weighs up options

Awards season on the domestic front is upon us and that’s always the cue for a frenzy of transfer activity.

Foremost among the players in demand is Corkman Adam O’Reilly. The 25-year-old was instrumental in Derry City winning the FAI Cup earlier this month and has been offered a lucrative extension to remain under an era, likely to be led by Stephen O’Donnell as incoming manager.

O’Reilly’s hometown club City have made a serious play to entice the bustling midfielder back to Leeside while a couple of the Dublin clubs, that match Derry’s European football appeal, have registered their interest. As a free agent from November 30, he’ll have his pick of clubs and there remains the possibility of moving to England for what would be a bargain deal from the club’s side.

City are busily trying to strengthen the side promoted from the First Division, already adding Kevin Long and Archie Meekison, but they’re all making inroads on recruiting Kaiyne Woolery. The former Bolton Wanderers and Swindon Town striker moved to Ireland in August but was unable to prevent the Bit O’Red being automatically relegated. The 31-year-old is viewed as an option to broaden depth in the forward line spearheaded by Ruairi Keating and Seáni Maguire.

Grassroots leagues enjoy clear run

Ten weeks into the grassroots season and there has yet to be a weekend disrupted by inclement weather.

Had the FAI got their way by now the transition to summer soccer would be underway for the youngest age-groups and the season be wrapped up.

From the last weekend in August, when schools returned, underage and amateur leagues have reported uninterrupted programmes, allowing them to make headway into their campaigns.

This week’s drop in temperatures indicate disruptions may arise in December but that’s the month when traditionally fixtures are curtailed. Under the ‘aligned calendar’ concept, the months of July and August were without games to facilitate summer holidays.

It took a long time for the FAI to realise they were fighting a losing battle in attempting to strongarm sceptical leagues and clubs into competing directly with the GAA season.

However, despite the FAI insisting the move would remain on track following the departure of its primary proponent, Marc Canham, an exemption system floated in 2025 constituted a tacit admission of failure.

Canham’s successor as director of football, John Martin, was far more practical in his approach, hastening its full demise in August of this year.

Expect the notional 2029 revisit to disappear into the ether.

More in this section

Sport

Newsletter

Sign up to our daily sports bulletin, delivered straight to your inbox at 5pm. Subscribers also receive an exclusive email from our sports desk editors every Friday evening looking forward to the weekend's sporting action.

Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Brand Safety FAQ Help Contact Us Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited