Irish Examiner view: Xi’s proposal must lead to real action

'A country with no warheads had every reason to take an interest in what might be done with everybody else’s'
Russian president Vladimir Putin, Chinese president Xi Jinping, and Russian US president Donald Trump arrive for a trilateral meeting at Kylin Villa Ton Thursday. Picture: Win McNamee/Pool/AP

Russian president Vladimir Putin, Chinese president Xi Jinping, and Russian US president Donald Trump arrive for a trilateral meeting at Kylin Villa Ton Thursday. Picture: Win McNamee/Pool/AP

Xi Jinping has offered the world a proposition worth taking seriously, including by the many who have seldom found reason to take him — or China — at his word. Nuclear weapons should be prohibited and destroyed, the Chinese president said at his meeting with US and Russian counterparts Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin in Shenzhen.

By the time the three men left the room, all had put their names to a declaration that “a nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought”. Between them, they are in a better position than most to see to it.

There are sound reasons to be sceptical of Xi. China’s nuclear arsenal has more than doubled since 2019, even as its president has continued to advocate the abolition of precisely the weapons his country is accumulating. The Americans and Russians, meanwhile, each possess several thousand more warheads than the Chinese. One can readily see why Beijing would like Washington and Moscow to go first. One can also see how comfortably another decade might pass while everybody waits.

Still, which part of what Xi said would his critics wish to dispute? Certainly neither the US nor Russia could find fault with the proposition that a nuclear war is unwinnable. Both subscribed to those same words in January 2022, as did China, Britain, and France. It is a curious feature of the nuclear debate that a president can say such a thing and be credited with statesmanship, while a campaigner who draws the obvious conclusion risks being dismissed as a crank.

Ireland has some experience of what the supposed cranks can achieve. In 1958, Frank Aiken, as minister for external affairs, brought the first of a series of resolutions on nuclear weapons before the UN. A decade later, when the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty opened for signature, Ireland was invited to sign first. More recently, Irish diplomats helped negotiate the 2017 treaty prohibiting nuclear weapons.

A country with no warheads had every reason to take an interest in what might be done with everybody else’s. It still does. The Shenzhen declaration commits the three countries to talks on reducing nuclear risks and preventing the spread of these weapons. That is worth having. The document sets no date for those talks, puts no ceiling on a single arsenal, and commits none of its authors to dismantling a warhead.

The distance between what Xi advocated in the room and what the three leaders agreed on paper can be measured in those omissions. A useful next meeting would give the world a date, a proposed limit, and some means of establishing whether the parties are keeping their word. Verification was invented for precisely the circumstances in which trust is in short supply.

In the meantime, the next time somebody tells a disarmament campaigner to be realistic, the campaigner might reasonably ask what is so realistic about expecting nine nuclear powers, through every crisis and every change of government to come, to get it right every time.

Soldiers must be supported 

On Tuesday, Natasha McCloskey told the inquest into the death of her son, Private Seán Rooney, what his loss had done to her family. On Wednesday, Trooper Shane Kearney, who had been travelling to Beirut airport to fly home for a funeral, gave evidence about the attack in which he was critically injured and his 24-year-old colleague was killed.

Yesterday, Corporal Josh Phelan became emotional as he recalled the separation of the two vehicles in their convoy. For the court, these were three successive days of difficult evidence. For the people giving it, nearly four years have passed since that night in Lebanon.

The Rooney family deserves the fullest account the inquest can establish. There will be difficult questions. Asking them is part of the duty owed to a young man who went overseas in the service of this country and whose family had every reason to expect him home.

The Defence Forces have a continued duty, too, to the soldiers and officers who must answer those questions, to those named in the evidence, and to others for whom the coverage alone may bring that night back as a traumatic memory. A soldier could have been inside the relative safety of Camp Shamrock and still have lost a friend. An officer may have been in the decision-making chain of command and may yet have reconciled with him- or herself how differently things may have played out.

Nobody should have to establish how close they were to the gunfire to merit a phone call. The measure of authentic support is what happens after court rises. Will anyone think to check in on these men and women again in a month, when the hearings are over and the person who said they were grand on the court’s steps might feel able to give a different answer? Those are questions the Defence Forces can act on now.

Generation game time 

Somewhere in Ireland this week, a manager approved two days’ annual leave for a member of staff heading to Vice City. We hope neither party was embarrassed by a subsequent enquiry about flights. 

Grand Theft Auto VI arrived yesterday, 13 years after its predecessor. In that time, people who once had to persuade a parent to buy them the game have become adults and many — for this one weekend at least — will find themselves giddy as teenagers again.

The previous iteration of the game sold nearly 235m copies worldwide. According to game publisher Rockstar’s parent company, the second trailer for this one clocked up more than 475m views across platforms in 24 hours. 

That was for the privilege of watching an advertisement. Whatever your weekend plans, spare a thought for those spending theirs in Rockstar’s version of Miami. Imagine going that far for the sunshine and keeping the curtains drawn until Monday.

More in this section

Revoiced

Newsletter

Had a busy week? Sign up for some of the best reads from the week gone by. Selected just for you.

Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Brand Safety FAQ Help Contact Us Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited