Francesca Albanese: Israel's impunity puts us all at risk

Ireland has an opportunity to lead, to give voice to millions of Europeans who refuse to accept this course, to stand on the right side of history and help Europe recover its moral and legal compass
A Palestinian woman grieves over the flag-draped remains of one of 70 Palestinians, including women and children, recovered from under the rubble of buildings destroyed in Israeli strikes in northern Gaza on Sunday. Photo: Bashar Taleb/AFP via Getty Images

A Palestinian woman grieves over the flag-draped remains of one of 70 Palestinians, including women and children, recovered from under the rubble of buildings destroyed in Israeli strikes in northern Gaza on Sunday. Photo: Bashar Taleb/AFP via Getty Images

We are at a critical moment. The stakes could not be higher: for Palestine, for international law, for Europe and for all of us.

The situation in the Occupied Palestinian Territory is catastrophic. Gaza lies in ruins. In over three years, Israel has killed nearly 75,000 Palestinians, including at least 21,700 children: an average of 20 children every day for more than 1,100 days.

More than 1,500 Palestinians have been killed since the “ceasefire” of October 2025. The genocide continues, with people corralled into one third of Gaza’s devastated territory. 

Palestinians cling to life amid rubble, human remains, deprivation, disease and vermin. As winter approaches, Israeli attacks, deliberate restrictions on humanitarian access and dwindling funding further erode their means of survival.

This devastation is produced with intent, triggering international law’s obligations to prevent, halt and punish genocide. Trump’s externally-imposed and failed Board of Peace repudiates 80 years of multilateralism and strikes at the heart of the Palestinian people’s inalienable right to self-determination.

In the West Bank, including East Jerusalem, the space for Palestinian life shrinks every day. Soldiers and settlers dispossess communities while towns and cities endure sieges and military attacks. Settler terror, home demolitions and restrictions on movement deepen this system of domination. 

These attacks are the latest and most extreme stage of a long-standing settler-colonial process of fragmentation and dispossession, carried out deliberately through every layer of the Israeli state, with the aim of erasing Palestinians as a people.

The International Criminal Court, the International Court of Justice and the international human rights system have been unequivocal in their findings on Israel’s violations and crimes, standing firm despite enormous political pressure. 

Their authority now faces a defining test: will states act on these findings? So far, the answer is a resounding “no”. The United States and Israel are cannibalising the rule of law, replacing it with lawlessness.

Palestine has exposed this system, with its people enduring its most brutal consequences. Senior Israeli leaders have openly articulated their intentions yet much of the West refuses to act according to the principles of the UN Charter, continuing to shield Israel from accountability. 

Expressions of concern over the ever-deteriorating situation in Palestine, or over US sanctions unjustly imposed on those advancing justice, ring hollow while European states continue to provide Israel with political, military and diplomatic support and bend to US pressure.

International law

The International Court of Justice ordered binding provisional measures in South Africa’s genocide case in January 2024 yet no meaningful collective European action has followed. The obligation to prevent genocide cannot await a final judgment of the court.

The ICJ’s July 2024 Advisory Opinion was a watershed: Israel’s continued presence in the Occupied Palestinian Territory is unlawful and must end entirely and unconditionally; Israeli settlers and soldiers must leave every inch of Gaza, the West Bank and East Jerusalem; Palestinian resources must no longer be exploited; and states must neither recognise nor assist this unlawful situation, regardless of any peace process. 

This demands a radical shift: abandon the discredited peace process mantra and make international law the framework for political action.

Yet the European Union has remained paralysed and complicit. Its credibility is under scrutiny and will be measured, not by endless declarations, but by its willingness to consistently uphold international law without exceptionalism or double standards.

Ireland has long defended Palestinian rights, international law and multilateralism. It is not too late to turn those commitments into action and principled leadership. 

Francesca Albanese: 'What happens to Palestinians today is the blueprint for what happens to us tomorrow.'
Francesca Albanese: 'What happens to Palestinians today is the blueprint for what happens to us tomorrow.'

Ireland can and should now lead efforts to implement the International Court of Justice’s Advisory Opinion and ensure that EU policies neither recognise nor assist Israel's unlawful presence in Palestine, including by suspending the EU-Israel Association Agreement.

The EU must act against Israel’s unlawful occupation in its entirety. Measures must go beyond settlements: the occupation is sustained by the Israeli state, its institutions, businesses and financial networks, enabling crimes which are now before two international courts.

Unfortunately, European countries and the EU institutions continue to arm Israel. It is time for it to end and for the European Union to enact comprehensive measures addressing trade, investments, military and dual-use technologies, corporate activities and institutional partnerships with Israel as a whole. 

Respect for international law must be the basic condition for relations with Israel while humanitarian assistance and reconstruction must serve Palestinian self-determination rather than becoming instruments of externally-imposed control.

Israel’s impunity puts us all at risk. I have long warned of the “Israelisation” of our societies. From Germany to the UK and Italy solidarity is criminalised, dissent suppressed, and power shielded from accountability. 

What happens to Palestinians today is the blueprint for what happens to us tomorrow.

Yet this unbearable injustice is also driving a structural shift, sustained by Palestinian steadfastness (Sumud), carried by our youth, and fuelled by the catastrophic failure of domestic and international legal systems to prevent or punish mass atrocities.

We must fix it before it is too late. Ireland has an opportunity to lead, to give voice to millions of Europeans who refuse to accept this course, to stand on the right side of history and help Europe recover its moral and legal compass.

  • Francesca Albanese is the United Nations Special Rapporteur on the situation of human rights in the Palestinian territory occupied since 1967.

More in this section

Revoiced

Newsletter

Had a busy week? Sign up for some of the best reads from the week gone by. Selected just for you.

Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Brand Safety FAQ Help Contact Us Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited