Free GP care for all sounds noble, but it could ruin what makes Irish healthcare great

Without a huge increase in GP numbers, Ireland's primary healthcare system risks replicating Britain's NHS, where unhurried, preventive, relationship-based care has been abandoned, and which has been paying the price in overcrowded waiting rooms and worsening outcomes ever since

The Irish College of General Practitioners has stated directly that universal free GP care is unachievable without a huge expansion in GP numbers.

I grew up in Britain with the NHS. For most of my adult life, a GP appointment meant 10 minutes — sometimes less — with a doctor who already had your name on a prescription pad. If you were lucky, you described your symptoms, got the script, and left. Blood pressure? Rarely checked unless you specifically ask. Weight? Not mentioned. Smoking? Perhaps a leaflet on the way out. Prevention was a luxury the system could not afford.

When I moved to Wexford, I discovered something different. My GP here listens. An appointment runs closer to 14 minutes — a figure confirmed by a 2021 cross-sectional study in BMC Primary Care, which found the Irish average at 13.7 minutes, nearly 50% longer than the UK's 9.2 minutes recorded in a landmark analysis of 28.5 million consultations across 67 countries. 

In that extra time, my blood pressure gets checked without prompting. My lifestyle gets discussed. The consultation feels like medicine, not a processing line.

That margin matters enormously, because it is precisely where prevention happens. A controlled trial in the British Medical Journal found extending GP appointments from 7.5 to just 10 minutes significantly increased health-promotion activity — blood pressure recording, smoking advice, alcohol discussions, and immunisation advice all rose. 

A subsequent systematic review concluded bluntly that slower doctors undertook more preventive procedures. And prevention pays. A review of 52 studies in the Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health found public health interventions deliver a median return of €14.30 for every €1 invested, counting health and economic benefits. The WHO puts the figure at seven-to-one over a decade, even under more conservative assumptions.

Ireland, uniquely in the EU, still charges most adults to visit their GP — typically €40-€65 per consultation. The Social Democrats last month brought a Dáil motion calling for universal free GP care for all by 2030, building on Sláintecare commitments the Oireachtas first endorsed nearly a decade ago. 

The intention is admirable. As TD Pádraig Rice noted, Ireland remains the only European country without universal primary care coverage — a verdict confirmed by a March 2025 editorial in The Lancet Regional Health. 

That is a genuine injustice, particularly for working families who delay seeing a doctor for financial reasons, a group that accounts for roughly a quarter of the population.

But good intentions and sound policy are not the same thing. The question is not whether everyone deserves good primary care — they do — but whether making all GP visits free overnight would actually deliver it. The evidence from Ireland's own experience counsels caution.

When free GP care was extended to under-sixes in 2015, daytime attendance by that age group increased by 20% to 21% within three years, with out-of-hours attendance rising by up to 29%. 

Emergency department attendances did not fall. The demand surge was real; the compensating savings were not. The ESRI estimates extending free care to the whole population would generate between 1.9 and 2.3 million additional consultations annually at a cost of €381m to €881m per year. 

That is potentially manageable — if the doctors are available to absorb the demand. They do not. Ireland needs an additional 943 to 1,211 GPs by 2040 simply to meet demographic growth, before any policy expansion. 

The Irish College of General Practitioners has stated directly that universal free GP care is unachievable without a huge expansion in GP numbers. The Irish Medical Organisation has warned of waiting lists emerging for the first time. Already, 74% of GPs cannot accept new private patients, and 79% cannot accept new medical card patients.

What happens when you flood a system at capacity? You get shorter appointments. You get the NHS. The British Medical Association now formally recommends a minimum of 15 minutes per consultation. 

The Royal College of General Practitioners' vice-chair called 10-minute appointments "a disaster". The system that eliminated cost barriers decades ago has squeezed out the time needed for prevention. That is not a coincidence; it is the documented consequence of demand saturation.

The answer is not to preserve the status quo. It is a targeted, means-tested expansion that protects GP capacity. GP Visit Cards — which provide free access without requiring a full medical card — should be extended immediately to all children under 19, to older adults who cannot afford to attend, and to anyone whose household income falls below a defined threshold. 

What's your view on this issue?

You can tell us here

This approach already exists in Irish law and can be expanded without the demand shock of overnight universalisation.

Build the workforce first. Expand training places, address emigration incentives, and create sustainable capitation agreements with the medical profession. Then move to universality from a position of capacity rather than crisis. 

The goal should be Irish-style general practice — unhurried, preventive, relationship-based — available to everyone. Not a replication of the British model that abandoned all of that in the name of free access, and has been paying the price in overcrowded waiting rooms and worsening outcomes ever since.

• Christopher Nial is a communications professional for FINN Partners Global Health Impact based in Wexford. He is originally from the United Kingdom. He does not represent any Irish clients in the public health space, and this is entirely his own opinion and not that of his employer.