Elaine Loughlin: We need to keep our schools open — but we also must make them safe

The teacher who sparked a curiosity and passion in their students — this cannot be passed on through a Zoom screen. But it doesn't mean we should accept unnecessary risks
Elaine Loughlin: We need to keep our schools open — but we also must make them safe

She didn't ram Yeats, Boland, Shakespeare or Plath into our heads, she didn’t have to.

Ms Carroll's sheer love of language was enough.

A generally quiet woman, the energy in her voice was enough to engage the room as she described how peeling potatoes could become an act more divine than any religious ceremony, just as Seamus Heaney had intended.

The gentle drop of each skin into an agricultural steel bucket, the only sound breaking the silence. Ms Carroll taught us that the simplest of words and sentences can often resound the loudest.

When all the others were away at Mass, I was all hers as we peeled potatoes.

Beyond the classroom, she got us involved in debating, organising a minibus to ferry us Covent girls to schools in Dublin with high gates and posh sounding names.

She entered us in short story and poetry competitions.

Most people can probably refer back to their own Ms Carroll, a teacher who had a lasting impact on them.

From the artistic primary teacher who encouraged creativity at a young age, to the PE teacher who spent afternoons standing on rain-sodden sidelines, or the one who spotted the student struggling with a trauma going on at home.

The maths teacher, geography teacher, Irish teacher, physics teacher or university lecturer who sparked a curiosity and passion for their particular subject.

This cannot be passed on through a Zoom screen.

As the Omicron variant takes hold, the Government and Nphet must acknowledge that this is the real reason we need to keep our schools open.

That's not to say that unnecessary risk should be tolerated.

With the Omicron variant now advancing across the country, we as a nation need to make individual decisions to ensure we keep our schools open in the new year.
With the Omicron variant now advancing across the country, we as a nation need to make individual decisions to ensure we keep our schools open in the new year.

Since March 2020, teachers and principals have had to up-skill, they have become experts in online learning and pods, have graduated in contact tracing and now are expected to be qualified in the acquisition of Hepa filters.

They have stood at whiteboards with the mantra 'schools are safe' constantly repeated at them from medics and ministers.

The constant 'schools are safe' refrain from the Government is like one of those overplayed Christmas tunes we all sing along to without listening to the words.

During a press briefing immediately after his state of the nation address on Friday evening, Taoiseach Micheál Martin again stressed that schools are "not drivers of the virus". Chief Medical Officer Tony Holohan reiterated that schools are "controlled environments".

When Virgin Media political correspondent Gavan Reilly tweeted out the Taoiseach's lines, the hundreds of comments in response had one predominant theme — disbelief.

One person suggested that anyone who can still say that a junior infants class is a controlled environment must never have visited a school.

It was also pointed out that classrooms remain a "controlled environment" but theatres with high ceilings and fresh air circulation are not, even when seated and masked audiences who have all shown Covid certs are limited to 50%.

Schools are only safe if they are made safe.

With the Omicron variant now advancing across the country, we as a nation need to make individual decisions to ensure we keep our schools open in the New Year.

But we also need the Education Minister Norma Foley to do her part.

Speaking in the Dáil during an education debate last week, Social Democrats TD Gary Gannon, in acknowledging Ms Foley was not there as she had left after 30 minutes, said: "I cannot help but feel this is symbolic of a department that is not in control of what is happening on the ground and has been absent for much of the time, while the crisis has got worse in our schools."

As we enter the final days of term two realities now exist — on the Government side schools remain safe, but in the classroom, cases are surging.

Mr Gannon pointed out that in the previous two weeks the highest recorded number of Covid cases was among those five to 12-year-olds who "sit in those cold classrooms every day" before going home to their parents and grandparents.

We were told by the Minister that there was no crisis in getting substitute teachers while at the same time school principals were going on Twitter to call for substitute teachers to go to their schools.

After continuously claiming that schools, the safe places that they are, don't require air filters, the Government finally relented last week by making €62m in funding available for primary, special and post-primary schools.

Donnchadh Ó Laoghaire: 'This grant puts these filtration systems in competition with other desperately needed projects within a school, and that is wrong, especially at a time when school budgets are already overstretched.'
Donnchadh Ó Laoghaire: 'This grant puts these filtration systems in competition with other desperately needed projects within a school, and that is wrong, especially at a time when school budgets are already overstretched.'

But this was not a full admission, instead, the extra money was announced under what Sinn Féin's education spokesperson Donnchadh Ó Laoghaire described as "the cloak of the minor works grant".

This grant "puts these filtration systems in competition with other desperately needed projects within a school, and that is wrong, especially at a time when school budgets are already overstretched," Mr Ó Laoghaire told the Dáil.

"It is putting filters in competition with broken windows, doors, gutters or whatever other items that are badly needed. This is at a time when kids are freezing in their classrooms with the windows open."

As we enter yet another Covid wave, schools need every support and should not be deciding between Hepa air filtration systems and replacing a boiler on the blink.

In refusing to let go of what many now consider a stubborn insistence that schools are safe, the Government is ignoring the real reason why we need to keep our children and students in the classroom.

To all the Carrolls out there a very merry Christmas and in the New Year let's hope the Government has truly made schools safe for your return.

Did you know?

The light that shines from an upstairs window at Áras an Uachtaráin, which is visible from the main road through the Phoenix Park, is a symbolic beacon. It is there to light the way for Irish emigrants and their descendants, welcoming them to their homeland.

It was first placed there by President Mary Robinson and builds on an old Irish tradition of people putting a candle in their windows on Christmas Eve.

Political week in years gone by

1889

Dec 27: The Cork Examiner reported that on Christmas Eve the streets of Cork “presented a very gay appearance”. In language truly of its time, the report continued: “All classes jostled one another in their eagerness to make their purchases. The horny-handed son of toil struggled with the wealthy-curled darling at the tobacconist shop.”

1948

Dec 21: The Republic of Ireland Act 1948, was signed into law formally ending the statutory role of the British monarchy in this country. The Cork Examiner reported that “in the quiet of his study” as a “newsreel camera hummed”, President Seán T Ó Ceallaigh signed the Bill with a fountain pen.

1967

Dec 27: No news made the news in 1967 where under the headline ‘Verdict: A Quiet Christmas’, the Cork Examiner reported that “indications are that Christmas was a very quiet holiday all round”.

1994

Dec 22: The Cork Examiner carried a front page picture of the new marine minister Hugh Coveney giving the thumbs up after alighting from the Government jet in Cork. He had arrived back from Brussels where he had “scored a major victory” for the Irish fishing industry by forcing tough curbs on Spain’s powerful fishing fleet in Irish waters.

2009

Dec 22: In roundtable interview with reporters, then Taoiseach Brian Cowen admitted that 2009 would go down as the most difficult year in his political life. But he added: “I’ve been lucky to have good colleagues who are equally determined to put the country first. This wasn’t about politics this year. The country’s future was at stake.”

Looking back

With the Dáil and Seanad on recess this week we are looking back, rather than forward, and what a year it has been...

January

We entered the year amid a Covid surge which put us back into level 5 lockdown as hospitals were under severe pressure. The much anticipated Mother and Baby Homes Commission report was also published. It revealed that government and other authorities knew everything but did little.

February

Health Minister Stephen Donnelly was forced to erect a 6ft fence around his home after being targeted by protestors.

March

President Joe Biden described his "deep, deep affection for Ireland," during a virtual St Patrick's Day meeting with the Taoiseach.

April

Announcing the reopening of retail, sports, hotels and nationwide travel, the Taoiseach announced that "a summer of hope and caution" was on the cards.

May

With restrictions on large gatherings still in place a marquee erected for wedding guests on a halting site was removed after gardaí turned up in force.

June

Pubs and other hospitality was allowed to reopen, but for outdoor service only as the Government further eased restrictions.

July

The Cabinet appointed former Children’s Minister Katherine Zappone to a new role of Ireland’s Special Envoy to the UN for freedom of opinion and expression, which sparked a summer-long controversy.

Meanwhile, thousands of people were told to get private PCR tests costing up to €400 to allow them leave the country as international travel resumed and the Government's Covid cert helpline buckled under the demand of calls.

August

A rescue operation was mounted to get as many Irish citizens out of Afghanistan after the Taliban took control.

September

The much-anticipated €20bn Housing for All plan was published. It promised to provide deliver 160,000 homes over the next five years.

October

The night-time economy was the last remaining sector to get the go-ahead to reopen.

November

Former Anglo Irish Bank chief executive Seán FitzPatrick died.

While you are here, why not sign up to our 'On The Plinth' political newsletter? Delivered direct to your inbox every Tuesday. Sign up here exa.mn/OnThePlinth

More in this section

Revoiced

Newsletter

Had a busy week? Sign up for some of the best reads from the week gone by. Selected just for you.

Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Brand Safety FAQ Help Contact Us Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited