CUH crisis: HSE chief and health minister will not be at Taoiseach's crunch meeting over hospital
Health minister Jennifer Carroll MacNeill and HSE chief executive Anne O'Connor. File picture: Sam Boal/Collins
Neither the health minister nor the head of the HSE will be with the Taoiseach when he holds crunch meetings with Cork University Hospital tomorrow, Monday, over the deepening crisis over staffing levels at the hospital.
That is despite Jennifer Carroll MacNeill and HSE boss Anne O'Connor being among the most outspoken critics of management at the hospital, including its chief executive Jennifer Kearney.
Ms Kearney will be at the meeting with Micheál Martin and it had been widely expected she would hold talks with Anne O'Connor.
However, the HSE tonight confirmed that Anne O'Connor would not be coming to Cork with a spokesperson giving no reason.
At the Oireachtas health committee just last week, Ms O'Connor admitted that she hadn't spoken to Jennifer Kearney about the staffing row which emerged in August.
At that point, Ms Kearney wrote to senior health officials to express concern about safety at the hospital heading into the winter. She warned them of unsafe conditions due to a shortage of more than 1,000 staff, inadequate staffing limits, and slow recruitment. Her claims were backed by clinicians at the hospital.
At the health committee Ms O'Connor accused the Cork hospital of “conducting its management business via the media with extraordinary regularity”.
She also told those present that she would not reiterate all of the investment put into CUH in recent years “except to say their increase in staffing this year is bigger than the combined increase in Beaumont, the Mater, St James’s, and Tallaght University hospitals”.
Read More
For her part, Ms Carroll MacNeill has been a frequent critic in recent months of how the Cork hospital has been run, saying the South West region has hired more people in this year than any other region and the hospital is significantly over its budget.
A spokesperson for the Dun Laoghaire TD, in confirming she would not travel to Cork, said Ms Carroll MacNeill would remain in “close contact” with the Taoiseach on CUH.
They added that the health minister engaged with patient safety experts on Friday, with independent assessments of CUH being provided.
The absence of the two women will be a blow to Taoiseach Micheál Martin.
The Government has sought to play down the significance of the meeting, suggesting Mr Martin is visiting the hospital in his capacity as a TD for Cork South Central, rather than in his role as Taoiseach.
Mr Martin too has described the engagement as being “low-key”, while adding it would be a “listening exercise”.
However, it had been seen as a way to finally resolve a dispute which has been festering since the summer.
Social Democrats TD and health committee chair Pádraig Rice criticised Jennifer Carroll MacNeill's absence from tomorrow's meeting saying the health minister has been “extraordinarily quiet” on the CUH crisis.
“I think the Government need to get on the same page on this," Mr Rice said, saying the meetings must conclude with solutions.
It comes as Liam Conway of the Irish Nurses and Midwives Organisation (INMO) called on Mr Martin to review the “multitude of staffing agreements that exist in the hospital”, particularly pointing to theatre staffing.
He said the Taoiseach must “recognise that unsafe staffing levels mean these services cannot operate to their full potential”.
Mr Conway said Mr Martin would see the “incredibly difficult conditions” nurses are working in, adding there is a need for an urgent review of the strategy of suppressing patient facing roles in CUH.
“There has been increased service capacity in CUH, but that must be matched with safe staffing levels across all wards, which currently is not the case,” he said.
Over the weekend, the Irish Examiner reported that over half of Cork’s TDs have backed an external independent assessment of staffing levels at CUH amid calls for a mediator to be appointed to resolve the bitter “personal” disputes between the hospital and the HSE.
- Tadgh McNally, Political Reporter



