Judge cuts fines against five Cork men caught with iron bars hunting wildlife with dogs

The judge at Cork Circuit Appeals Court said they 'would present as a very intimidating bunch of men if you arrived on someone’s land with dogs and bars'

Five men appeared at Cork Circuit Appeals Court appealing the severity of fines imposed on them for hunting on privately owned lands with dogs in contravention of the Wildlife Act. File picture: Larry Cummins

Groups of men carrying iron bars and accompanied by dogs of various breeds hunting foxes, rabbits and badgers, would be very intimidating for the owners of land, a circuit court judge said.

Five men appeared at Cork Circuit Appeals Court appealing the severity of fines imposed on them for hunting on privately owned lands with dogs in contravention of the Wildlife Act.

Orla Meere, barrister, said that because of the fact that the men were on social welfare they were appealing the fines imposed on them which ranged from €500 to €750.

“Essentially, it is the same application. They accept their action, they are just seeking leniency,” Ms Meere said.

Judge Sinead Behan said: “One of the problems with this is that it is private land and there have been instances where owners are intimidated by men appearing on their land with bars and dogs and that has led to terrible consequences, sometimes fatal.

You would present as a very intimidating bunch of men if you arrived on someone’s land with dogs and bars, apart altogether from wildlife considerations.

“This is a serious matter. If this is activity you get involved in as a hobby it can lead to damage to property, let alone the unfortunate animals you are pursuing.” 

The judge said that because of the men’s financial and family circumstances she would reduce the fines in all cases to €300.

Sergeant John Kelleher said that at 10.10am on March 14, 2021, at Kilboy, Riverstick, gardaí observed a large number of men spread out across two fields hunting with dogs.

“They saw three vehicles parked up on the side of the road with a dog trailer attached to each vehicle. They had at least three different dog breeds, as well as bars and a shovel. The dogs were off-lead and hunting around the fields. They land was private property,” Sgt Kelleher said.

Each man was fined on a charge that on March 14, 2021, not being the owner of land, he entered the land for hunting foxes without permission, contrary to the Wildlife Act.

43-year-old Michael Foley of 30 Awbeg, Rivervalley, Mallow, County Cork, had been fined €500, 32-year-old Anthony O’Reilly of 32 Ballinure Avenue, Mahon, Cork, was fined €750, 30-year-old Joseph O’Reilly of 32 Ballinure Avenue, Mahon, Cork, was fined €500 and 45-year-old Timmy O’Reilly of 3 Meelagh Drive, Mahon, Cork, was fined €750. 

Following the appeal, those fines now stand at €300 in each case. 56-year-old Patrick O’Reilly of 32 Ballinure Avenue, Mahon, Cork, had been fined €300 originally so his appeal was effectively withdrawn.