Industrial school survivor claims State failed her sisters over criminal record clarification
Survivor Miriam Moriarty Owens said she had been given clarity about her own criminal record, but she was still waiting for the same recognition for her sisters, who were sent to industrial school as children. File picture
An industrial school survivor has accused the Government of failing her two late sisters by not assuring her that they do not have criminal records, which was the common perception during the historical process of placing children in such institutions.
Miriam Moriarty Owens said her sisters Joan and Aine "were never criminals" and that it was an appalling injustice that she has not received official confirmation that they are not.
The Kerry woman said she had been given clarity about her own criminal record, but she was still waiting for the same recognition for her sisters, who were sent to industrial school as children.
It was a popular misconception that children sent to industrial schools were sent there because of criminality, which led to further stigmatisation.
This year, all those who endured time in the industrial schools were promised by the State that they were not seen as criminals, as part of an official Government apology to survivors of institutional abuse.
Ms Moriarty Owens, who became a prominent figure outside Leinster House last year when she joined three other survivors on hunger strike over access to enhanced medical cards, received a letter earlier this year from justice minister Jim O’Callaghan.
Read More
The letter said that the State did not regard her as having committed a criminal offence and that "no criminal conviction was recorded against her in relation to her detention in Pembroke House between June 16, 1959, and July 27, 1970".
However, Ms Moriarty Owens questioned the value of the assurance when her sisters had not been afforded the same treatment.
She said the perception of criminal records had damaged survivors’ lives, preventing some from travelling abroad or securing good jobs.
Ms Moriarty Owens has been protesting outside the Dáil every Tuesday.
Mr O'Callaghan said in a statement: "The State did not, and does not, regard individuals as having committed a criminal offence, and no criminal record is recorded against them, by virtue of their detention in any industrial school.
"No person and, in particular, no agency of the State should regard these individuals as having committed a criminal offence or having a criminal record.
"The Department of Education and Youth (DEY) have responsibility for the historic industrial and reformatory schools and holds the relevant records, although they acknowledge that these records are incomplete.
"Officials in my Department have been in contact with the Department of Education and Youth (DEY) on this matter and will continue to assist DEY with the provision of certificates confirming that no criminal record is recorded against individuals by virtue of their detention in an industrial school, where requested to do so."



