Homeless boy in emergency accommodation barred from hotel garden

Homeless children put up in a hotel are banned from playing in the garden but dogs are allowed, a parliamentary watchdog has heard.

Homeless boy in emergency accommodation barred from hotel garden

Fr Peter McVerry revealed a seven-year-old boy in the emergency accommodation asked his mother why animals could go into the space on a sunny day but his family could not.

“I heard the story of one family, they were living in an hotel bedroom, they are not allowed to mix with other residents, they are not allowed to eat in the restaurant,” said Fr McVerry.

“They have to come in the back door, [they’re] not allowed in the front door.

“They weren’t allowed to sit in the garden. It was a lovely sunny day and all the paying residents were in this garden and the parent decided to bring the kids for a walk.

“While walking through the garden the seven-year-old boy saw a bowl on the ground with water and says to his mammy, ‘Mammy why is the dog allowed in the garden and we’re not?’”

The campaigning priest detailed the impact of homelessness after telling a parliamentary watchdog that Taoiseach Enda Kenny should declare a national emergency over chronic housing shortages.

“He would do if we had a foot and mouth disease in the morning,” he said.

More than 6,100 men, women, and children were homeless at the end of April and living in emergency accommodation such as B&Bs, hostels, and two and three-star hotels — an unprecedented crisis.

The trust told the special Oireachtas committee on housing and homelessness that councils should be using compulsory purchase orders to buy vacant properties which could be turned into units for homeless families.

“I don’t know what the local authorities’ problem is,” said Fr McVerry.

“The National Roads Authority had no difficulty compulsorily purchasing houses and land when it wanted to build motorways. There was no constitutional problem.

“Why can’t we compulsorily purchase houses for the far more important issue of providing people with homes.”

Fr McVerry estimated that at least 2,000 families people have been made homeless as a result of the Department of Social Protection not increasing rent supplement payments.

The trust called for another 1,500 modular units to be built in the greater Dublin area and for the rapid builds also to be used for student accommodation to free up 5,000 housing units in the rental sector.

Fr McVerry said he expected 100,000 people or families to be on social housing waiting lists this year.

Also at the committee hearing, Social Justice Ireland said €10bn was needed to solve the housing and homeless crisis.

It said about a third of the money needed is lying in reserves controlled by bad bank Nama and half of it could be raised through credit unions.

Michelle Murphy, research and policy analyst with the group, said there was no explanation for the slow pace of work to complete the country’s 668 unfinished housing estates.

“I suppose the issue here is the scale of the problem,” she said. “If you are going to eliminate waiting lists and build the units required you are looking at about €10bn worth of expenditure.

“It will be very difficult to raise your revenue over the lifetime of this government to that amount just to fund the social housing issue.

“The issue we have here is that there has been, for want of a better word, inertia in terms of dealing with the problem.

“There is funding there, there are reserves which should be used because we have a funding crisis.”

More in this section

War of Independence Podcast

A special four-part series hosted by Mick Clifford

Available on

Commemorating 100 years since the War of Independence