At the High Court, Mr Justice Nicholas Kearns, in dismissing his legal challenge, told him nothing had been put before the court that suggested his life and safety was in any imminent danger from other prisoners and courts should only intervene in the gravest of cases.
Nash sought the transfer on the basis he was under threat from other prisoners and had become significantly suicidal. He has already served a 15-year life sentence in Arbour Hill, Dublin, for the murder in 1997 of two people in Ballintober, Co Roscommon.
Last April, Nash, aged 42, was given another life sentence after he was found guilty of the separate 1997 murders of Sylvia Sheils, aged 59, and Mary Callanan. aged 61, at their sheltered housing in Grangegorman in Dublin. That sentence runs from April last.
Following that sentence he was taken to Mountjoy Prison where he claims he was under threat from other prisoners and under 23-hour lock-up for his safety. He sought a return to Arbour Hill, where he claims he had been living a peaceful life, but was later transferred to the Midlands Prison where he remains and says he is also under threat.
The court heard Nash refused to take food for several weeks which resulted in him being brought to hospital. After he started taking food again he went back to the Midlands Prison.
The judge said prisoners could not expect or demand arrangements for where they serve their sentences and it wasn’t appropriate for courts to adopt a role of micro-managing criminal detention arrangements. He said threats of suicide should not be capable of being cited by a prisoner as an appropriate basis for a transfer unless the suicidal condition had been brought about as a direct result of actual or apprehended violence which placed the prisoner at risk. The court accepted that prison life often would have instances where prisoners might be at loggerheads with each other.
“Unrealistic worries or exaggerated over-reaction to remarks, looks, gestures or minor scuffles can never constitute an adequate reason for treating a threat of suicide as a basis for ordering prison authorities to transfer a prisoner from one prison to another much less to a prison of his choosing,” said Judge Kearns.
In relation to specific threats allegedly made against Nash at the Midlands Prison, which it was claimed rendered him suicidal, he said the evidence of the threats was vague.
The judge said that none of the prisoners named by Nash was in a position to harm him in the Midlands Prison as they were kept separate from him.
The High Court president said Nash’s mental state seemed more attributable to an adjustment disorder following his convictions for the Grangegorman murders rather than any perceived threats. He said there was no evidence that any risk of suicide would abate if Nash was sent to Arbour Hill.
The judge said the court’s decision did not preclude him from seeking a transfer to Arbour Hill in the future.
Adjourning the proceedings until October, Judge Kearns said co-operation, rather than threats of suicide, were likely to be of greater assistance to Nash in this regard.