Drug case based on ‘coincidences’
Addressing the Circuit Criminal Court in Cork Blaise O’Carroll, senior counsel, said prosecution had suggested that the law did not like coincidences but he said on behalf of Joseph Daly, 41, from 9 Carisbrook Avenue, Bexley, Kent, “coincidences do happen.” Mr O’Carroll said: “If what he says could reasonably be true, you must acquit… Whatever was going on, Joe Daly was unaware of it. He has given you his account and run the gauntlet of cross-examination.
“He has gotten into the witness box and looked you straight in the eye to tell you he knew nothing about what was happening.”
During the trial, there was evidence that Joseph Daly brought a 4x4 and rigid inflatable boat (rib) over on the Pembroke-Rosslare car ferry because his brother Michael Daly asked him to.
The jury of nine men and two women was told that Michael Daly has been in custody since May of this year on charges related to importing €€200,000 worth of illegal drugs into Britain.
Mr O’Carroll referred to evidence from Joseph Daly’s sister and uncle which presented the accused as a very good person, “who was on the side of the angels rather than on the other side”.
He referred to the fact that, for instance, his company accounts were up to date with the revenue office and that everything about him was open and transparent in that sense.
“Do we have a situation where a decent human being is being exploited — exploited and used by someone who has a nefarious agenda of his own?” Mr O’Carroll asked.
Mr O’Carroll challenged the inference put forward by the prosecution that the relatively low level of Daly’s company profits was a motive for getting involved in drugs crime. Conversely, Mr O’Carroll said it could be said that with his low income he had nothing to contribute to the purchase of a “gi-normous” quantity of drugs.
In relation to what he described as the “hullabaloo” made by the prosecution about him leaving the scene at Dunlough Bay when he believed it was his brother in the water with all the drugs and the sunken rib.
The senior counsel said the defendant was thinking, “‘Wow! I brought this rib over, who is going to believe me?’ Who can blame him for reacting the way he did?”
In relation to Daly’s evidence that he began to tidy up the mess in one of the rented houses when he found it looking like a tip, Mr O’Carroll said it was indicative of a naive and innocent person who did what came naturally to him.
Next in the trial, lawyers for Martin Wanden, 45, and Perry Wharrie, 48, of 60 Pryles Lane, Essex, England, will address the jury.
All accused deny possessing cocaine with intent to sell or supply on July 2, at Dunlough Bay, Mizen, Goleen, Co Cork.




