Crash injury claim referred to Supreme Court
The Motor Insurance Bureau of Ireland has lodged papers appealing a ruling made by the High Court in January.
Mr Justice George Birmingham said Elaine Farrell was entitled to make a claim against the Bureau for the injuries she suffered in the accident in 1996.
Her sister Marie was killed in this accident at the junction of Cookstown and Fortunestown in Tallaght, Dublin 24.
She claimed the driver, who was uninsured, lost control of the vehicle and caused it to collide with a wall as a result of which she suffered personal injuries.
The High Court ruled the bureau was an offshoot of the state and had a responsibility to compensate Ms Farrell. The bureau has appealed this decision to the Supreme Court on the grounds it would be liable for all compensation costs.
Its argument is expected to question whether it should be considered an extension of the state and carry the same weight of responsibility as Government.
In a separate case, the Health Service Executive is fighting in the High Court to establish if it should be considered an arm of the State in a battle with the Valuation Office about its commercial rates bill.
Cork County Council has lost a similar case at the Valuation Tribunal in its attempt to be considered a state agency and gain an exemption from rates.
The bureau’s Supreme Court case is considered a test case for 50 other claims.
In 1997 the Government and the MIBI decided not to pay compensation to Ms Farrell because she was sitting on the floor of the van. She fought this and won a case in the EU Court of Justice in April 2007.




