Most older people not helped by new scheme, say critics
Only those who are considered to have high dependency will be entitled to the scheme, while the remainder will be entitled to home care packages and home help promised by the Government.
The Minister for Health Mary Harney, said about a quarter of those currently in nursing homes do not need to be there: “We estimate that there’s 6,000-7,000 people in nursing homes at the, moment in Ireland who have very low levels of dependency and if they had been provided with home support they would have been able to stay at home. That’s why I have increased greatly the home care package to €5,000 in 2007. All the evidence suggests that if people can stay at home they lead a higher quality of life and on average live two years longer. So we’re going to make the nursing home the place of last resort.
Labour’s Liz McManus said: “I support the principle that everything possible should be done to allow elderly people to remain in their homes and among the community.” She said proper community supports should be in place to allow this to happen.”
The support group for older people, Age Action, welcomed the plans but said: “Despite the failing of the existing system highlighted by the report on Leas Cross, the Government has introduced no legislation to prevent a recurrence of serious sub-standard care institutions in other nursing homes.”
The group also claimed that the new scheme is “ageist”.
Head of Advocacy, Eamon Timmins, said: “Older people, many who paid taxes all their lives, are being told that because there are so many of them, they will have to fund some of the cost of their care if they become frail and vulnerable. Is the Government proposing to adopt the same approach to all sections of society? If there was a baby boom, would it mean the end of free education?”
Michael O’Halloran from the Senior Citizens Parliament said: “We do not want to spend the last years of our lives in long term care, therefore there’s a need to put in place a system that enables an older person to live as long as possible in their own community. That means putting in services and the ones that are already there need further resources and further staffing and so on.”




