Doctor says life begins at fertilisation
Former Master of the Coombe Hospital Dr James Clinch was giving evidence in the second stage of the frozen embryo case where a woman is seeking orders preventing the destruction of three frozen embryos in a Dublin clinic which were left over after successful IVF treatment.
“In general, if in doubt a doctor comes down on side of life,” Dr Clinch said, a retired obstetrician and gynaecologist, and former chairman of the Irish Medical Council’s ethics committee.
He added: “Who knows when life starts? Nobody does. Nobody in this court room does unless they have a halo. Where there is any doubt you come down on the side of life.”
An embryo, Dr Clinch said, has all the genetic material to make a human being and you would instinctively come down on the side of the embryo.
The court examined the guidelines set down by the Irish Medical Council for the medical profession.
A passage of the Irish Medical Council’s ethical guidelines for 2004 was read to the court, which stated: ‘any fertilised ovum must be used for normal implantation and must not be deliberately destroyed’.
Asked had the Medical Council formed a view as to when life begins, Dr Clinch said there had been 17 meetings where it came up but on balance if you think there might be life you preserve it.
The couple who had IVF treatment five years ago have since separated and Mr Justrice Brian McGovern has already ruled that the estranged husband did not give his consent for the implantation of the frozen embryos in his wife’s uterus.
The woman claims she is entitled to an order vindicating the right to life of the three embryos.
She is also looking for an order vindicating both her and the embryos’ right to family life, the return of the frozen embryos to her and an order preventing their destruction.
Mr Justice Brian McGovern is now deciding on issues of public and constitutional law. There is also the issue as to whether the husband can be forced to become a parent against his will.
The case is set to examine the status of the frozen embryos under the Constitution, along with the right to a family and the right to privacy under the Constitution and under the European Convention on Human Rights.
The case before Mr Justice Brian Mc Govern continues today.




