O’Donoghue trial: Pathologist’s cross-examination

STATE Pathologist Dr Marie Cassidy was yesterday afternoon quizzed by Blaise O’Carroll SC, defending, on her evidence of the day before.

Mr O’Carroll said: All of your findings in relation to the post-mortem examination of the remains, externally and internally, would have been recorded by you on January 13 (the day after Robert’s body was found).

Dr Cassidy: Yes.

BOC: The ladies and gentlemen of the jury are aware it was about three days later when Wayne O’Donoghue made contact with An Garda Síochána (and told them what happened to Robert). I’m just wondering, between the time you conducted the post mortem and you finalised your report, was (O’Donoghue’s) statement given to you?

MC: I wasn’t given the statement in its entirety but I was given... excerpts.

BOC: Were the excerpts in relation to the incident between Wayne O’Donoghue and Robert Holohan?

MC: Yes.

BOC: You were able to put the excerpts and these descriptions into the melting pot as you formulated your conclusions in relation to the post mortem.

MC: In this particular case I had come to certain conclusions at the end of the post-mortem examination and this information was relayed to the (gardaí) and this was without having any input from anyone.

Later she said: “I usually try not to allow other people’s thoughts or even statements to influence greatly my conclusions.”

Later, Mr O’Carroll turned to the events of January 4 when Wayne O’Donoghue said he firstly grabbed Robert in a headlock and then gripped him by the throat.

BOC: You talked yesterday that your findings were consistent with an armlock (being used). Was that on the basis of what you had seen (in the post mortem) or was this from the excerpts of Wayne O’Donoghue’s statement?

She said she had arrived at the conclusion from the post mortem, saying: “I had proffered this as an explanation for my findings.”

MC: In cases I have dealt with where compression of the neck had been due to an armlock, you rarely see any marks on the skin. The only real markings on the skin were from (Robert’s) necklace which had been pressed into the skin. To get such a line across the neck suggests something broad had been pressed into the neck. In the beginning I thought an arm had been around his neck but there was also another form of compression of his neck or most likely that he had been gripped or grabbed by the neck.

BOC: The jury have heard statements taken by members of An Garda Síochána on January 16 where he (O’Donoghue) describes grabbing hold of Robert in an armlock and jerking him away from the bike and putting his left hand around his throat.

MC: Yes.

Mr O’Carroll then asked Dr Cassidy if the findings in her post-mortem report in fact backed the version of events given by Wayne to the guards.

BOC: Your findings corroborate the account that Wayne O’Donoghue gave to An Garda Síochána?

MC: They do.

BOC: Wayne O’Donoghue described that he grabbed Robert Holohan in a headlock and jerked him against (O’Donoghue’s) Fiat Punto, put his hand to his throat and put his back against the car. The injuries (to the back of Robert’s body), you say they could have been caused by having being pushed against a wall or the ground?

MC: Yes.

BOC: Being pushed against the car would account for the injuries you discovered?

MC: Yes.

BOC: If he was pushed forcibly into the car?

MC: Yes.

Earlier the court heard that the way people died from strangulation was complex and not just a matter of starving the lungs of air.

Gripping the throat cut off the blood supply carrying vital oxygen to the brain and also stopped “used” blood leaving the brain to be refreshed by air in the lungs.

Strangulation also interfered with a key nerve, known as the Vegas nerve, and this would trigger messages from the brain to slow down the heart or even stop it beating altogether, the court heard.

BOC: Is it correct that, for example, if someone is grabbed in a headlock, that the Vegas nerve can be interfered with and the person will die as a result of being caught in an armlock.

MC: I have dealt with cases like that in the past.

BOC: Is it possible that when Wayne grabbed Robert in the armlock, that he may well have precipitated a crisis in Robert Holohan by interfering with the Vegas nerve?

MC: If that was the case, then you are implying that as he (afterwards) goes to grab him by the throat - and if there’s no struggle - then there could have been a slowing of the heart.

BOC: In the statement of Wayne O’Donoghue, he does not describe Robert as struggling. What would that suggest to you? Assuming, for argument’s sake, it is correct, what would that suggest to you?

MC: That at that stage Robert was not struggling because he was either not afraid of the situation or just not reacting to the situation. One possibility of him not reacting was that he had already become injured. He may well have been partly asphyxiated or had (irregular heartbeat). That would have prevented him from struggling.

BOC: When a human being finds that their airways or the (related) blood vessels are blocked, does the human being spontaneously struggle for air themselves?

MC: In some cases, they do. They may well be pinned down and unable to move but it’s normal instinct if your airways are blocked, then people do struggle to breathe.

BOC: Is that more likely if someone is standing up as opposed to pinned to the ground?

She said she did not know but said people would struggle.

BOC: Will they try to release the pressure?

MC: They can try and do in some cases.

BOC: If the Vegas nerve is inhibited and the brain sends a message to the heart to slow down or causing it to stop, can such a person be resuscitated?

MC: That’s a difficult one.

She said some people believed that the heart could return to its natural rhythm once.

In cases she had dealt with, there did not appear to be cases of the heart returning to normal.

Mr O’Carroll then asked if such an incident happened in hospital, would it be possible to revive the heart of such a person?

She said that hospitals had specialist equipment for that but outside hospitals, there was nothing that could be done to kickstart the heart in those circumstances.

BOC: Am I correct in thinking that in bringing back the heart and bodily organs that the brain would be in a (damaged) state and you talk of someone being in a permanent vegetative state?

MC: Yes, that’s highly likely.

He then told Dr Cassidy about a report he had obtained from Professor Jack Crane, the State Pathologist in Northern Ireland.

The report was compiled by Professor Crane who had assessed Dr Cassidy’s post-mortem report and the evidence she gave in court the previous day.

Mr O’Carroll, quoting from the report about the strangulation, said: “The findings would suggest that little in the way of force was applied and that force may not have been maintained for a long period.”

MC: I agree in general terms that the force applied to the neck was sufficient to leave bruises but not sufficient to damage his Adam’s apple. With regard to the length of time, it is difficult to say how long it was applied.

Professor Crane’s report then said there was no evidence of a sexual assault or a violent struggle between Wayne O’Donoghue and Robert Holohan.

MC: I would agree with that.

After Dr Cassidy finished her evidence, it was the turn of Ivan O’Flynn, a technical specialist with mobile phone company O2, to take the witness stand. He said he and a colleague had traced records of movements of Robert’s O2 mobile phone and were able to pinpoint where the device was on January 4.

He said that at 2.35pm and 3.15pm the phone was at Robert’s home. At 4.15pm it was most likely to be either in the area of his home or between his house and Ballinacurra.

Just seconds after 5pm, the phone gave a signal, placing it between Aghada and Inch.

More in this section

Lunchtime News

Newsletter

Get a lunch briefing straight to your inbox at noon daily. Also be the first to know with our occasional Breaking News emails.

Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Brand Safety FAQ Help Contact Us Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited