Skipping the gym? Bank analysts are paying attention

A potential early warning of stress that could spread to credit-card and mortgage payments
The fitness-centre data may be more relevant for credit cards and personal loans than for the much larger mortgage-lending business.

The fitness-centre data may be more relevant for credit cards and personal loans than for the much larger mortgage-lending business.

A potential sign of consumer stress is catching the attention of bank equity analysts: missed gym payments.

The percentage of people failing to pay their gym membership fee has risen for five consecutive months, data compiled by the UK's Office for National Statistics shows. It’s a metric that RBC Capital Markets analyst Benjamin Toms is tracking because he sees it as a potential early warning of stress that could spread to credit-card and mortgage payments, which would put pressure on banks.

Toms, who covers lenders like NatWest Group and Lloyds Banking Group, says it’s one of the reasons he’s cautious on bank stocks. As he sees it, a struggling consumer and Britain’s cost-of-living crisis will feed through to the banking industry, and lenders may ultimately have to raise impairment provisions, which would reduce profits and drag down share prices.

“You’ve seen a big tick up,” said Toms in an interview, highlighting the latest data showing 6.6% of attempted direct debits for fitness facilities failed in September due to insufficient funds. “For me, if I’m starting to struggle a little bit with cash, one of the first things I stop paying is my gym membership, because that is a luxury item,” he said.

While the fitness-centre data is niche, JPMorgan Chase & Co. analyst Sheel Shah said it may be more relevant for credit cards and personal loans than for the much larger mortgage-lending business. He added that gym memberships tend to skew toward younger consumers and may therefore be less representative of the broader population.

And to be sure, the broader UK economy has been resilient. Meanwhile ONS data shows monthly loan failures have remained broadly stable at around 5%, while mortgage failures have held at about 0.9%. Failed electricity and gas payments have declined from their late-2025 peak.

But there are signs of trouble in subprime lending. Vanquis Banking Group Plc has noted higher charge-offs — when a lender writes off a loan or credit-card balance it considers unlikely to be recovered — amid rising individual insolvencies. The small-cap stock fell 40% after an Oct. 29 trading update.

RBC’s Toms sees the gym data and Vanquis’s comments as reasons for caution on the larger banks. He has sector perform ratings on NatWest and Lloyds Banking Group, the equivalent of neutral — a relatively contrarian position, with the majority of analysts assigning buy ratings.

Investors “need to consider the risk factor of a deteriorating asset quality into next year,” Toms said. “One thing that gets bank share prices to de-rate downwards is when they’re experiencing poor asset quality.”

Bloomberg

More in this section

The Business Hub

Newsletter

News and analysis on business, money and jobs from Munster and beyond by our expert team of business writers.

Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Brand Safety FAQ Help Contact Us Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited