Is another French revolution imminent?

If the the far-right Marine Le Pen and the independent centrist Emmanuel Macron square off in the second round of the presidential election, it will be a first in 60 years, says Zaki Laïdi.         

Is another French revolution imminent?

IN A few weeks, France will elect its next president. Given the French executive’s considerable powers, including the authority to dissolve the National Assembly, the presidential election, held every five years, is France’s most important. But the stakes are higher than ever.

The two frontrunners are the far-right, National Front’s Marine Le Pen, and Emmanuel Macron, who served as economy minister under Socialist president François Hollande but who is running as an independent.

If, as expected, Le Pen and Macron face off in the election’s second round, on May 7, it will be a political watershed for France: The first time in 60 years that the main parties of the left and the right are not represented in the second round.

France has not endured such political turmoil since 1958, when, in the midst of the Algerian War, General Charles de Gaulle came to power and crafted the constitution of the Fifth Republic.

That 1958 shift, like any great political rupture, was driven by a combination of deep underlying dynamics and the circumstances of the moment.

Today is no different. First, the underlying dynamic: The rise, as in most developed countries nowadays, of popular mistrust of elites, feelings of disempowerment, fear of economic globalisation and immigration, and anxiety over downward social mobility and growing inequality.

These sentiments — together with the French state’s historical role in fostering national identity and economic growth — have contributed to a surge in support for the National Front.

Le Pen’s nationalist, xenophobic message and populist economic policies resemble those of the far-left candidate, Jean-Luc Mélenchon.

Marine Le Pen
Marine Le Pen

Although support for the National Front has been growing for a decade, the party has been kept out of power by France’s two-round electoral system, which enables voters to unite against it in the second round.

And, given the National Front’s inability to make alliances, power has remained in the hands of the main parties of the left and the right, even as France has moved toward a tripartite political system.

Now, Macron is taking advantage of circumstances to blow up the tripartite system. Macron’s great insight, which few initially recognised, was that the right-left divide was blocking progress, and that the presidential election amounted to a golden opportunity to move beyond it, without the help of an organised political movement.

At a time when the French people are increasingly rejecting the traditional party system, Macron’s initial weakness quickly became his strength.

It helped that, as Macron recognised, both the right and the left have fragmented.

This is particularly true on the left, which is divided between a reformist current, led by former prime minister, Manuel Valls, and traditionalists, represented by the Socialist Party candidate, Benoît Hamon. The Socialists’ problems are compounded by a radical left working to eliminate them, much as Spain’s left-wing Podemos party has sought to replace the Socialist Workers’ Party there.

The source of the mainstream right’s travails is less clear. Its forces remain united on economic and social issues. Until a few months ago, its presidential candidate, the Republicans’ François Fillon, was expected to lead the pack in the first round by a wide margin.

Emmanuel Macron
Emmanuel Macron

But a scandal over his personal conduct (he allegedly paid his wife and children for non-existent jobs, while he was a member of parliament) damaged his candidacy, probably fatally.

Whatever the reason for the right’s decline, Macron has benefited substantially from it, as well as from the rifts afflicting the left. Now, there is a real chance the young independent could be elected president on May 7, upending the Fifth Republic’s political system.

But an electoral victory is just a first step. To govern in France’s hybrid presidential-parliamentary system, Macron would need to secure a majority in the National Assembly.

This opens the possibility of two scenarios.

In the first scenario, Macron quickly gains a parliamentary majority, as French voters seek to reinforce his mandate in June’s National Assembly election. This is conceivable, but not certain: it is here where the lack of an organised political movement on the ground remains a weakness for Macron.

That is why the June election could give rise to the second scenario: cohabitation with a parliamentary coalition comprising a small right-wing faction, a large centrist faction, and a hopelessly divided left-wing faction.

Such a development would be familiar in many European countries. But in France, where republicanism gave rise to the left-right ideological spectrum that shapes politics throughout the West today, it would be a genuine revolution. It could spell the end of the Socialist Party.

Given the symbolic power of the left-right divide, France’s voters and political leaders alike have long tended to frame the country’s problems in ideological terms. The public and its politicians have little experience with government based on broad coalition agreements.

This partly explains why the political system becomes gridlocked, sometimes making reforms difficult to implement, and why Macron’s message, which includes clear reform plans, is so unusual for France.

If Le Pen somehow comes out on top, French politics — not to mention the European Union — will be turned upside.

But even the ostensibly moderate Macron represents, in his own way, a truly radical stance. With both candidates likely to make it to the second round, France is on the verge of a political revolution, regardless of who wins.

Zaki Laïdi, a professor at Sciences Po, Paris, was a political adviser to French prime minister, Manuel Valls. Copyright: Project Syndicate, 2017.

More in this section

Budget 2022 Logo

What impact will this  year's budget have on you and your business.

The Business Hub

News and analysis on business, money and jobs from Munster and beyond by our expert team of business writers.

Sign up
Puzzles logo

Puzzles hub

Visit our brain gym where you will find simple and cryptic crosswords, sudoku puzzles and much more. Updated at midnight every day. PS ... We would love to hear your feedback on the section right HERE.

News Wrap

A lunchtime summary of content highlights on the Irish Examiner website. Delivered at 1pm each day.

Sign up

Our Covid-free newsletter brings together some of the best bits from, as chosen by our editor, direct to your inbox every Monday.

Sign up