State paid almost €9m in legal fees and compensation due to assaults in prisons

File photo

The State has paid out almost €9m in compensation and legal fees to staff and prisoners due to assaults and "slopping out" practices - including €100,000 to two families whose relatives died from "self-inflicted" wounds.

The figures have been given to TDs amid ongoing concerns over overcrowding and safety levels in jails.

In a detailed letter to the Public Accounts Committee, the Department of Justice's secretary general Aidan O'Driscoll said between 2014 and last year the Irish Prison Service and State Claims Agency paid out €8.3m to victims of assaults or injuries.

The figure includes €2.4m in compensation payments and €5.9m in associated legal fees - €2.7m of which relates to "slopping out" cases.

A breakdown of the figures show:

  • 2014: €249,137 in compensation payments and €834,462 in legal fees
  • 2015: €468,059 in compensation payments and €660,577 in legal fees
  • 2016: €647,167 in compensation payments and €2,235,464 in legal fees
  • 2017: €492,126 in compensation payments and €999,887 in legal fees
  • 2018: €502,646 in compensation payments and €1,183,305 in legal fees

In addition to the pay-outs, Mr O'Driscoll also confirmed officials paid the families of two prisoners €50,000 and €51,737 in 2016 and 2017 respectively.

In his letter, he said: "The payments were made to the families of prisoners who had died from self-inflicted injuries while in custody."

The scale of the payments and legal fees - and the €100,000 in payments to the families of two dead prisoners - is likely to cause significant concern among human rights groups due to repeated fears over the scale of overcrowding in some Irish prisons.

However, Mr O'Driscoll sought to downplay the concerns by saying there are no international comparisons available to show if Ireland's pay-outs rate is within norms, other than the fact our 5% rate of the population being in prison is not unexpected.

Speaking at last week's PAC meeting, committee chair and Fianna Fáil TD Sean Fleming said there is a clear need to obtain further information on the scale of injuries in prisons.

He added that it is "very sad to be reading that €50,000 and €51,000 has been paid respectively in payments to the families of prisoners who died from self-inflicted injuries in custody". He said the department must clarify exactly what the cases involved.

The fresh questions to the Department of Justice came after the Irish Examiner reported last month that a number of prison officer sexual harassment protected disclosure complaints have been made by jail staff since last summer.

The department confirmed five sexual harassment protected disclosure complaints have been made since last July by staff concerned over their personal safety in work.

More on this topic

Prison authorities not giving 'sufficient attention' to circumstances around vulnerable inmate deaths

Families campaign to ensure killers stay in prison

Report into surveillance in prisons due out soon

Michael Clifford: Keeping a close eye on Flanagan’s next move

More in this Section

Gardaí launch murder investigation into death of woman in Mayo

Latest poll indicates five-point lead for Fianna Fáil

Farmers misled by Government on EU beef fund, claims TD

Post-mortem carried out on Mayo woman found dead yesterday


Appliance of science: Why does your stomach rumble?

We can overcome with historical unification of mankind

Tolerance for a rural way of life

Exploding stars put humans in upright positions

More From The Irish Examiner