Judge says cryptocurrency is ‘a crime proceed’

Judge says cryptocurrency is ‘a crime proceed’

Cryptocurrency worth €25,000 held by a man serving a prison sentence for drugs offences are the proceeds of crime, the High Court has ruled.

In a case that “broke new legal ground” relating to online currency, Ms Justice Carmel Stewart granted orders sought by the Criminal Assets Bureau (CAB) in respect of 2,000 units of a currency known as ether or ethereum, worth about €25,000 found in a crypto-currency ‘online wallet’ belonging to Neil Mannion.

Manion opposed CAB’s application on the grounds that his rights had been allegedly breached by an investigation into his holding of this cryptocurrency. Those arguments were dismissed by the judge.

Mannion is serving a six-and-a-half year prison sentence in Wheatfield Prison arising out of a search by gardaí at premises located on Dublin’s South Circular Rd in November 2014.

He admitted the premises was being used as a drug distribution centre for the sale of illegal drugs.

Mannion, aged 37, of Mount Drummond Avenue, Harold’s Cross, Dublin also admitted trading on the darknet sites known as the Silk Road and Agora under the alias the Hulkster.

In 2015, a judge at Dublin Circuit Court jailed Mannion after he and a co-accused admitted possession of LSD, amphetamine, and cannabis resin with intent to sell or supply at South Circular Rd on November 5, 2014.

CAB also brought proceedings against Mannion claiming that funds contained in various bank accounts, credits cards and in bitcoin, were the proceeds of crime.

Those proceedings were settled in February 2016.

CAB found the ether/ethereum currency in an online wallet after examining several computer devices seized during the search.

The ethereum did not form part of the first set of proceedings as at the time the action that particular cryptocurrency had not started operating as a trading currency.

Following a review of the case, CAB decided to bring a fresh application in July 2016 seeking to have ether, which had begun to be traded as a currency, deemed the proceeds of crime.

In a case that “broke new legal ground”, Ms Justice Stewart said Mannion’s constitutional and legal rights were not breached.

However, the arguments raised by Mannion were not without merit, and the judge said a great deal of the State’s investigation into the matter was potentially undermined by the intricacies of data privacy rights and cryptocurrency exchanges.

While the complications in the investigation did give rise to legitimate questions, they did not amount to a breach of his rights.

The judge said that such a breach could arise in a future case, and it would be prudent to prepare for such potential difficulties.

More on this topic

High Court hears case of unknown 'John Doe' in psychiatric hospital for over 30 yearsHigh Court hears case of unknown 'John Doe' in psychiatric hospital for over 30 years

Boy with litany of curfew breaches remandedBoy with litany of curfew breaches remanded

Teen ordered to write apology letters to victims of crime sprees in Cork cityTeen ordered to write apology letters to victims of crime sprees in Cork city

Vulnerable woman threatened to procure and infect people with Covid-19, court hearsVulnerable woman threatened to procure and infect people with Covid-19, court hears


More in this Section

Dozens of parishioners attend drive-in church service in AntrimDozens of parishioners attend drive-in church service in Antrim

Two arrested after €23k of prescription drugs seized in WaterfordTwo arrested after €23k of prescription drugs seized in Waterford

'We need continuity at this time' - Ciaran Cuffe against change of Green Party leader'We need continuity at this time' - Ciaran Cuffe against change of Green Party leader

HSE gets reassurances late filing of Covid-19 data by hospitals has not been repeatedHSE gets reassurances late filing of Covid-19 data by hospitals has not been repeated


Lifestyle

Esther N McCarthy finds funky fabric and Bantry baskets as well as exploring virtual galleries. Wish List: In pursuit of funky fabric and Bantry baskets

Pubs have been closed across this island for over two months. Can you imagine if they were closed for 14 years? To mark the centenary of the introduction of Prohibition in the US, Robert O'Shea selects examples of its cultural legacyWhat did Prohibition ever do for us?

Des O'Driscoll looks at some of the top picks on the TV today.TV highlights: A new 'make-under' dating show and Kevin McGahern paints celeb protraits

More From The Irish Examiner