Hair stylist fired for anxiety gets €7k: Apprentice returned from sick leave to be told she was a liability

By Darragh McDonagh

A hairdresser has been awarded €7,000, after a salon fire her because she suffered from anxiety.

The dismissal constituted discrimination on grounds of disability, said the Workplace Relations Commission (WRC).

And an employment law expert has warned that businesses need to support workers who have mental health difficulties.

An adjudication hearing of the WRC heard the complainant had been working as an apprentice hairdresser at the salon for seven months when she was diagnosed with anxiety in April 2017.

She sent a text message to the owner of the salon, explaining she had been experiencing panic attacks and that she had been advised by a GP to take some time off work.

She told her employer that she had been prescribed medication and that she would have a sick certificate when she returned to work four days later.

The owner replied by saying that she “didn’t do” sick days.

Upon her return to work, the complainant felt that she was being ignored.

Two weeks later, she was taken aside by the owner and told that she was a liability.

The business could not be run around her, the owner said.

The complainant asked what she had done wrong and was told that the salon and its clients had no problem with her, but her “head was all over the place”. She understood this to refer to her anxiety.

The hairdresser was asked to get her belongings and leave.

She told the WRC that she was physically upset and crying, as she passed by staff and clients on her way out of the salon.

She was left “badly scarred” by the experience and had felt unable to return to hairdressing.

She had since resumed an old job in a factory, where she has no contact with the public.

In her evidence, the salon owner claimed that there were longstanding performance issues with the complainant.

The claim was denied and WRC adjudication officer Kevin Baneham noted the only documentary evidence presented in this regard was a self-assessment sheet completed by the complainant herself.

The former employee told the WRC that the low marks she had given herself in that exercise were a reflection of her low self-confidence, rather than any deficiency in terms of performance.

The owner said it was a “fabrication” to say that the complainant had been dismissed due to her mental health.

She said that the salon stylist has depression and has worked with her for 14 years.

However, Mr Baneham concluded that the complainant had been dismissed because she was imputed to have a disability — anxiety — and said the effects of the discrimination warranted an award of €7,000.

Employment law specialist Jason O’Sullivan, of JOS Solicitors, said employers are obliged to make “reasonable accommodation” for employees who have a disability, including mental health conditions.

“There does appear to be a need for employers to start finding better ways to support employees who are experiencing mental health difficulties,” Mr O’Sullivan said.

“Until employers start taking such affirmative action, they will continue to fall foul of the law.”

More in this Section

Minister rules out suspending NAMA work pending report into sale of NI loans

Study looking at gender diversity in surgery “an important message for the HSE"

Government deferred Local Property Tax review for political reasons, says FF

Garda worry over rising speeding and drink driving


Review: Theatre, Ulster American

Review: Beyoncé, Homecoming

Wish List: Mellow yellow in the bedroom and beyond

10 ways to help protect your child’s online reputation

More From The Irish Examiner