UN nuclear chief slams US over Syria nuclear intelligence

The head of the United Nations nuclear monitoring agency, Mohamed ElBaradei today criticised the US for not giving his organisation intelligence information sooner on what Washington says was a nuclear reactor in Syria.

IAEA director general Mohamed ElBaradei also chastised Israel for bombing the site seven months ago.

The White House broke its silence about the issue last night, just hours after members of the House of Representatives Intelligence Committee were briefed on the alleged reactor being built secretly by North Korea.

US intelligence officials said evidence included dozens of photographs taken from ground level as well as footage of the interior of the building taken by spy satellites after the Israeli strike.

The IAEA’s mission includes trying to keep nuclear proliferation in check, and it depends on member states for information in trying to carry out that task.

The agency is currently investigating allegations Iran tried to make nuclear weapons, and it is using not only its own research but intelligence provided by the US and other members of the 35-nation IAEA board.

“The director general deplores the fact that this information was not provided to the agency in a timely manner, in accordance with the agency’s responsibilities under the nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT), to enable it to verify its veracity and establish the facts,” the statement said.

Additionally, “the director general views the unilateral use of force by Israel as undermining the due process of verification that is at the heart of the non-proliferation regime,” it said.

Mr ElBaradei was briefed by telephone yesterday by John Rood, the US undersecretary of state for arms control.

Additionally, a senior US official, who demanded anonymity because of the sensitivity of the matter, said a US intelligence team was in Vienna to brief IAEA representatives.

A senior diplomat linked to the IAEA said Mr ElBaradei had already let his displeasure be known to Mr Rood during the US official’s phone call over the delay between the time the information became available to the US and when he was informed of it.

US Congressional Intelligence Committee members also expressed anger yesterday over the seven-month time lapse before their committee was briefed.

Top US intelligence officials who briefed reporters in Washington yesterday said they had high confidence in the judgment that North Korea had aided Syria with a nuclear programme whose aim was to produce plutonium. But they claimed only low confidence for the conclusion that it was meant for weapons development, in part because there was no reprocessing facility at the site - something that would be needed to extract plutonium from spent reactor fuel for use in a bomb.

The alleged reactor was within weeks or months of being functional when Israeli jets destroyed it, a top US official said.

The official said the facility was mostly completed but still needed significant testing before it could have been declared operational.

Repeating its previous stance, Syria, in a statement issued last night denied the allegations.