America plays emotional tribute on Sept 11 anniversary

With quavering voices, parents and grandparents of those killed at the World Trade Center in New York slowly read the names of the victims today to mark the third anniversary of the attacks that brought down the twin towers.

Moments of silence were observed at 8:46 and 9:03 am (1246 and 1303 GMT), the times two planes slammed into the towers on September 11, 2001, and at 9:59 and 10:29 (1359 and 1429 GMT), when the two towers collapsed.

Many of the family members cried quietly and embraced each other.

“Every day is hard, but this day is a little bit harder,” said Nancy Brandemarti, who was attending the ground zero remembrance for the first time. “This day is just a day to think about him.”

At Arlington National Cemetery in Washington DC, there was a moment of silence at 9:37 am (1337 GMT), the time that another hijacked plane hit the Pentagon, where 184 people died. In Pennsylvania, more than 1,500 people gathered in the field where the fourth plane went down, killing the 40 passengers and crew aboard Flight 93.

President George Bush and first lady Laura Bush also observed a moment of silence on the White House’s South Lawn as the nation began a day of remembrance.

At the trade centre site in lower Manhattan, parents and grandparents stood in pairs at two podiums, reading the list of the 2,749 people killed there – a recitation that lasted more than two hours.

They read slowly and precisely, and added poignant dedications when they reached the names of their own loved ones. “And our loving son, Paul Robert Eckna, our tower of strength – we love and miss you,” said Carol Eckna.

Mayor Michael Bloomberg, Governor George Pataki, and former Mayor Rudolph Giuliani each delivered readings. Pataki’s quoted former President Dwight Eisenhower, describing losses of the Second World War: “There’s no tragedy in life like the death of a child. Things never get back to the way they were.”

As the reading of names began, other family members of victims descended the ramp into the pit of the trade centre site and laid flowers in two small reflecting pools meant to evoke the footprints of the twin trade centre towers. Others scrawled messages on the edges of the pools.

The area, seven stories below street level, is considered sacred ground by many. It was there that rescue workers combed the debris with rakes, painstakingly searching for the tiniest fragments of human remains.

Last year, children recited the names of the dead, and on the first anniversary, it was dignitaries, community leaders and some relatives of victims. This year, parents and grandparents had the honour.

Pat Hawley, 44, was among the family members at the site this morning. Hawley, of Charlotte, North Carolina, said he comes to the ground zero ceremony every year to remember his older sister, Karen Sue Juday.

“It seems like it gets harder every year, because it’s that much more time since I’ve been able to talk to my sister and be with her,” he said.

After the fourth moment of silence, Rosanne Cash sang a muted rendition of the traditional Irish ballad “Danny Boy.”

At Arlington National Cemetery, Defence Secretary Donald Rumsfeld joined relatives of those killed in the Pentagon near a large granite memorial marker that bears the names of each victim.

“The lives that were lost on September 11th have meaning. They live on as a testament to a country that is courageous, that is determined, to a people that are resilient despite great loss, and to a cause that continues until that mission is accomplished and beyond,” Rumsfeld said.

Family members laid flags at the marker and ran their fingers across the names inscribed.

Both Bush and Democratic presidential nominee John Kerry spoke on the anniversary of the attacks. Bush used the occasion to warn of continued danger and pledge victory in the war on terror.

“We will not relent until the terrorists who plot murder against our people are found and dealt with,” Bush said in a rare live radio address from the Oval Office.

Kerry praised the spirit of the country in the days and months after the attacks. “We are one America in our prayers for those who were taken from us on September 11 and for their families,” he said. “And we are one America in our unbending determination to defend our country to find and get the terrorists before they get us.”

In a field in western Pennsylvania where Flight 93 went down, volunteers rang two large bells as the names of each of the plane’s 40 passengers and crew were read.

“No words, no memorials, can ever replace all that you have lost,” Homeland Security Secretary Tom Ridge said to the victims’ families at the ceremony.

In Boston, a small plane pulled an American flag behind it as about 150 family members of September 11 victims paused for a moment of silence. Air Force Colonel Jim Ogonowski, whose brother John, piloted one of the hijacked planes, urged grieving families to remember more than the horrors of that day.

“I ask you to remember what followed the attacks,” he said. “Strangers helping strangers, neighbours helping neighbours, acts of good will everywhere. That’s the part of September 11th the terrorist don’t want to remember.”

Three years on, work still continues to identify the 20,000 pieces of human remains recovered from the trade centre site. The medical examiner’s office has identified about 1,570 victims, or just 60 percent. They do not expect to match the remains of every victim because some remains were too badly damaged in the fiery collapse.

Meanwhile, much has changed at the 16-acre site where the 110-storey towers once stood. A 20-ton granite cornerstone was laid on July 4 – US Independence Day – for the 1,776-foot-tall Freedom Tower, the skyscraper expected to be completed by 2009. The tower’s height in feet is meant to reflect the year the United States declared independence from Britain.

A few blocks from the site, friends and families of the 73 people who died at Windows on the World, the restaurant at the top of the trade centre, tossed roses into the Hudson River for each of the victims.

“We used to be a family and more than a family. We used to say, ‘God bless Windows on the World”’, said Fekkek Mamdouh, who was a waiter there.

At sundown, light beams that evoke the twin towers will be projected upward from a lot near the site, to remain on through the night. The memorial lights were first seen on March 11, 2002, with a plan to light them each year for the anniversary.

Today also marked the beginning of a competition to design a permanent national memorial to honour Flight 93’s passengers and crew. The memorial site encompasses 2,200 acres, including the spot where the plane crashed.