‘Chattering class' parents refusing MMR vaccine

UK doctors today attacked ‘‘chattering class’’ parents who refuse to have their children immunised with the triple MMR vaccine.

Parents who raise concerns about the measles, mumps and rubella vaccine are threatening the health of other children, delegates at the British Medical Association conference claimed.

Uptake of the jab has fallen since concerns were first raised in 1998 that it was linked to a rise in autism and bowel disorders.

Immunisation rates have fallen to below recommended World Health Organisation levels, promoting fears that the immunity of the whole population could be threatened.

Parents in some parts of the country have travelled abroad or paid privately for single vaccinations against the individual diseases.

But the single jabs are not as effective and some doctors are concerned that offering parents a choice will cause vaccination rates to fall still further.

Delegates at the BMA’s annual conference in Bournemouth overwhelmingly voted against a motion calling for single vaccines to made available on the NHS.

Dr David Sinclair from Fife, Scotland, said: ‘‘Single vaccines lead to more children’s deaths and disability.

‘‘This is a recipe for deaths in children - no more, no less.

‘‘It is pandering to the chattering classes and not to our children’s health.’’

Chairman of the BMA Dr Ian Bogle, who is a GP, said: ‘‘For me, it is a matter of parental choice against the greater public health and the issue if the public health must win.’’

But Dr Ian Robbe, senior lecturer in public health at the University of Wales in Cardiff, accused doctors of adopting ‘‘paternalistic’’ attitudes over the MMR vaccine.

He said: ‘‘This is about the issue of respect that I offer as a doctor to a parent or patient.

‘‘The evidence on MMR is very mixed. I think not to respect the parents position is not to give people the right to make a choice - it is taking choice away from them.’’

He added: ‘‘We can encourage and explain and exhort people to have a vaccine but we should not impose it on them.’’

Jackie Fletcher, from the campaign groups Jabs, which wants to see single vaccines re-introduced, said: ‘‘Parents do not take the decision lightly to seek out the single vaccine here and abroad.

‘‘They are worried about the MMR vaccine but still go to great lengths to ensure their children get protection against the diseases.’’

She added: ‘‘There are many scientific questions parents want answered and whether the Government likes it or not, there are a lot of legal cases (surrounding the MMR autism) going forward.

‘‘In the countries where MMR is used, there are concerns being raised.

‘‘It is appalling that parents who want to protect their children but only using a single vaccine, are being denied that choice.’’