Buyer's remorse: why GAA is shifting mood on minor back to Under 18

At present, 21 of the 32 counties have adopted U18 as their minor grade. Another seven organise theirs at both odd and even grades, while just four apply odd ages
WNNERS: Cork's Eoghan Ahern celebrates at the final whistle after the Rebels' All-Ireland MFC final win over Tyrone in Newbridge. How many more inter-county minor campaigns will be at Under 17? Pic: Sam Barnes/Sportsfile

WNNERS: Cork's Eoghan Ahern celebrates at the final whistle after the Rebels' All-Ireland MFC final win over Tyrone in Newbridge. How many more inter-county minor campaigns will be at Under 17? Pic: Sam Barnes/Sportsfile

At this stage, it doesn’t appear a question of if minor inter-county level returns to U18 but when.

Only for a moratorium, Munster GAA would have brought a motion to Congress to that effect earlier this year.

Three years ago, former Dublin footballer and manager Dr Pat O’Neill had given a presentation on burnout and overloading on teenage players that helped persuade delegates to reject Kerry, Longford and Tyrone’s proposal to switch from U17 to U18.

As less than a third of delegates supported it (32%), it couldn’t be revisited, as per rule, for another three years. The likes of GPA chief executive Tom Parsons warned of the “slippery slope” the GAA would be going down were they to back it.

Cork GAA chief executive Kevin O’Donovan spoke in favour of the motion, pointing out that U17 was not a developmental grade at inter-county level. “All we have done is pushed that training load down another year and increased pressure on development squads down another year,” he said.

Where the joint motion tripped up was not including decoupling. Armagh delegate Paul Duggan said the GAA were “duty bound to try and limit the number of teams that a talented 18-year-old is available for”.

Munster GAA are proposing U18 players would be prohibited from playing for their club adult teams for the duration of their county’s involvement in a minor championship.

To accommodate the rural club, there is a school of thought that might be relaxed. An U18 inter-county player may be allowed to play for the lowest-graded adult team in his club during his involvement with the minors.

The feeling is some allowances should be given to clubs who heavily depend on their starlets. As Cork senior hurling manager Ben O’Connor said in 2022, “The threat the GAA put out that if we change the age grade back to U18 there will have to be decoupling; that’s fine if you are in a club with a big pick. But if you are from a rural club where a 17-year-old is better than a lot of your older fellas that are there, and he can’t play, I think it is just madness.” 

At the same time, the GAA want to avoid a return to the days of players being pulled from pillar to post. The duration of the All-Ireland minor championship could be reduced. This past year’s football competition was 107 days, hurling was 98.

It may take a Special Congress next year to come to a suitable motion but the GAA at national level understands the mood has shifted and what is on the ground has to be reflected.

In 2023, Central Council allowed counties to determine their minor grade as they see fit. The shift back to U18 has been huge. At present, 21 of the 32 counties have adopted U18 as their minor grade. Another seven organise theirs at both odd and even grades, while just four apply odd ages. Laois are seriously considering reverting to even.

It’s 10 years since the GAA chose U17 at minor level across club and county arising from the burnout study. Making his pitch for the change, then GAA director general Páraic Duffy pointed out a significant number of 18-year-olds were sitting their Leaving Certificate and A Levels.

Over time, a sense of buyer’s remorse has developed. The minor pressures that had been on Leaving Cert students remain for 17-year-olds. For those 18-year-olds sitting exams, they face more onerous U20 challenges while, as O’Donovan rightly pointed out, 16-year-olds were being exposed to heightened demands.

As former Meath footballer and manager Colm O’Rourke, a former school principal, put it in his 'Sunday Independent' column, “I supported the move to 17 initially as I thought it would remove problems around the Leaving Cert. Instead, it exaggerated it, with the best players either on minor or U20 squads – the rule of unforeseen consequences. And minor is time enough for full-scale county action.” 

A compromise U19 level, which would have incorporated U17 and U20, was one of the outcomes from a talent academy review in late 2019. Following the pandemic, it was eventually voted on in February 2022 but received 55.6%, falling short of the required 60%.

It’s understandable to believe the knock-out effect of an U18 inter-county minor level will be U20 moving back to U21, although that would potentially double the commitments for the leading 21-year-olds.

It’s unlikely the two grades are going to be changed at the same time, however. For the GAA, it’s solving one problem at a time.

More in this section

Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Brand Safety FAQ Help Contact Us Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited