Duncan Casey: Irish rugby is too niche to prioritise World Cups over Six Nations consistency

Munster’s 2022 quarter-final against Toulouse in the Aviva attracted 40,000 spectators.

There was much handwringing in the fortnight that followed Ireland’s defeat to New Zealand and consequent exit from the Rugby World Cup. We had discussion points aplenty: a Mayo-esque quarter-final curse, our inability to peak at just the right time, a mental block, and plain old bad luck. These and more were offered up to explain how a side that seemed utterly invincible, who had amassed 17 wins on the trot, could be dumped out of rugby’s flagship competition at the first serious hurdle.

There was merit to much of the chatter. It was true to say luck was a factor. Losing by a single score to a side that ultimately finished one point behind the winners of the Webb Ellis trophy illustrates just how close Ireland were. You make your own luck, however, and on an evening that saw them play 10% below the levels we have grown so accustomed to, Ireland were unable to make their own luck when they most needed to.