GAA tied up in knots in dead duck Rules series
Don’t think for a second that the team Ireland are facing in Cavan on Saturday and Croke Park seven days later are Australia.
That might be the way it’s being projected by GAA chiefs but they realised back in May that the AFL weren’t living up to their side of the bargain when their chief executive Andrew Demetriou told Páraic Duffy they were considering sending an all-indigenous team to Ireland.
As Duffy recalled of the AFL’s suggestion a couple of months later: “We discussed it and felt that in the end, it’s up to the Australians to send whatever team they want. But it’s very hard to say it’s a team representative of all teams and players in the AFL because it’s not. Their argument was the indigenous players were very keen on it. I suspect that the last few years they’ve had trouble getting their best players to play and they want to recognise the contribution of the indigenous players to the AFL. But we do have concerns.”
Those worries are nowhere to be seen in advertisements where we are told the opposition is ‘Australia’.
Their official title is actually the Australian Indigenous All Stars but then this series has always been peppered with confusion. Its biggest selling point is violence after all, the one thing that could finish it for good.
The hope is a bunch of players, either Aboriginal or of Aboriginal origin, rightly proud to represent their people will provide a contest over seven days (incidentally they will perform a haka-like war-cry before each test).
However, the portents aren’t positive. Coming together for a first collective training session just eight days out from the first test doesn’t exactly inspire confidence. Some of the best Aboriginal talent the AFL has to offer won’t be travelling while the squad’s star player Lance Franklin, likely to be a co-captain, only arrives in Ireland from holiday today and will then leave for home after the first test.
Professionals they may be but just three of the 21-man squad have previous International Rules experience. The fact they are favourites with the bookmakers says more about how well Australian teams have done in Ireland in the past than the potential of the current group.
That’s not to say our own players have taken it to their heart this year. There were some marquee names who, when contacted by manager Paul Earley were not falling over themselves to sign up for the series.
But when — not if — the series dies a death, the culprits will be the Australians. From down under two years ago, this newspaper reported the AFL were giving serious thought to ending their involvement in the series. Their public utterances may have betrayed that view but privately, prominent individuals in their hierarchy felt it was no longer financially viable.
Their own players, not to mention the Australian people, had lost interest in the compromise concept as indicated by the 22,921 and 12,545 attendances in the Melbourne Etihad and Gold Coast Metricon Stadiums.
The International Rules serves a purpose for the GAA and by that we don’t mean providing Gaelic footballers with the highest representative honour. Contrary to what some might say, that will always be wearing a county jersey. We mean it provides a barometer for our own game. From 2008 to 2010, the possession-based style was contrary to the quick release required in International Rules.
It was hardly coincidental that Ireland lost both tests three years ago.
With the better counties now instructed to kick-pass more, Ireland shouldn’t, pardon the pun, run into too much trouble.
That’s all well and good but going back to the best-forgotten Kevin Sheedy years, it’s been the AFL who have been treating the GAA like an inferior dance partner.
The GAA may have had the bigger call on the conditions put in place to ensure the future of the series but then it was a rare occasion when they had the AFL over a barrel.
When the AFL asked for a year’s hiatus in 2009 because of economic difficulties at home (as if there weren’t any in Ireland) in the GAA’s 125th year, the association obliged.
All along, they have continued to entertain a sporting organisation whose contempt or indifference to this partnership has reeked.
It’s the GAA’s own fault that they now find themselves selling a competition that just doesn’t ring true. Put in language the Australians would understand, it’s just not cricket. Sadly the visitors were marked absent from the series long before this year.
*Email: john.fogarty@examiner.ie




