Action needed on plastic additives linked to sperm decline, experts warn

Sperm approaching a female egg. Across the world, sperm counts have been declining at a rate of about 1% a year for the past 50 years. Picture: PA 

Action must be taken to curb the use of plastic additives linked to plummeting sperm counts, a leading reproductive scientist has warned, as splits over chemical regulation contributed to the collapse of a crucial treaty on plastic pollution.

Across the world, sperm counts have been declining at a rate of about 1% a year for the past 50 years, and human fertility has been diminishing at a similar rate, studies have shown.

Increasing levels of obesity, sedentary lifestyles and ageing populations have all been held up as possible causes. But according to Dr Shanna Swan, professor of environmental medicine and public health at the Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai in New York City, environmental factors play the most significant role.

Swan said the decline was “largely, but not entirely due to toxins in the environment that have the ability to interfere with steroid hormones”.

In 2017, Swan and her colleagues published a meta-analysis showing a decline in sperm counts of almost 60% among men in North America, Europe, and Australia between 1973 and 2011.

CLIMATE & SUSTAINABILITY HUB

In 2023, they repeated the research, extending the study to 2018 and including previously unavailable data from Africa, Asia, and South America, and made even more shocking findings.

“We separated the countries into western and non-western for analytic purposes, and in both we found a significant decline,” Swan said. “And the other thing that we found, which was at least as alarming, was that if you looked at all of the studies going back to 1973 you see a 1% per year decline. But if you look at studies published after 2000, you see an over 2% decline."

Swan’s warning comes amid rising alarm at the impact of chemical toxicity on human and environmental health. Two weeks ago, a report published by Deep Science Ventures warned that chemical pollution was “a threat … of a similar order as climate change”.

The decline in sperm rates since about 1950 stands in an inverse relationship to the explosion in the use of plastics. Swan points out that there are now well-established links between common additives to plastics and falling sperm counts.

“Phthalates are chemicals that are put into plastic to give it flexibility and make it soft and flexible,” Swan said. “So anytime you pick up a soft water bottle or tubing, like medical tubing, or a food container that’s soft, you’re going to be touching phthalates.

“Then, on the other side, the evil twin of phthalates are the bisphenols. While phthalates make plastic soft and flexible, bisphenols make it hard and inflexible. And phthalates lower testosterone and the bisphenols increase oestrogen.” The effects of these and other endocrine-disrupting chemicals were particularly profound on foetuses and embryos developing in the womb, Swan said. She had previously carried out research into the effects of phthalates on unborn male babies, finding that exposure at a critical point in gestation could lead to subtle deformities in sexual development.

What's your view on this issue?

You can tell us here

Negotiators left Geneva last Friday having failed to reach an agreement on an comprehensive treaty to end the plastic pollution crisis. This was after oil- and gas-producing nations objected to calls for limits to production and curbs on chemicals.

Almost 100 nations had signed a declaration calling for a “legally binding obligation to phase out those most harmful plastic products and chemicals of concern”.