Martin’s health plan fighting for its life

MICHEÁL MARTIN’S newest health reform plan was fighting for its life last night after doctors and opposition parties declared major elements of it unrealistic and unworkable.

The Hanly report, released by the Minister for Health yesterday, calls for a radical restructuring of hospital services and doctors’ working arrangements inside 10 months, with further major changes to follow over the next decade.

Hospital consultants, who will be among the professionals most affected, said many of the changes were welcome but impossible to implement within the timeframe.

Irish Hospital Consultants Association (IHCA) general secretary Finbarr Fitzpatrick said: “It’s not realistic and the minister knows it’s not going to happen.”

The association’s response creates a pressured atmosphere for the negotiations which must now begin completely to reshape the consultants’ contract in what is set to be the first of many industrial relations headaches for the minister.

He also came under criticism from the opposition, who accused him of deliberately holding back details of which services will be moved from which hospitals until after the local elections for fear of a backlash from affected communities.

The plan was drawn up in response to the EU Working Time Directive, which comes into effect next August and insists on a 25% reduction in the number of hours worked by junior hospital doctors who work on average 75 hours a week and provide the majority of hospital services.

Its recommendations include:

Doubling the number of consultants and making them provide 24-hour cover.

Halving junior or non-consultant hospital doctors (NCHDs) and cutting their hours to 58 by next August and 48 by 2009.

Concentrating Accident & Emergency units and other complex and high-support services in regional hospitals with a population base of at least 350,000.

Using smaller hospitals for an expanded range of elective surgery, day clinics and community care only.

Around 20 hospitals are earmarked to lose services although they were not named in the report, which focused only on the Mid-Western Health Board and the East Coast Area Health Board.

Plans have yet to be drawn up for the other eight health boards and none can be acted upon without the National Hospitals Office which has not yet been established.

Mr Fitzpatrick said the issue of bed shortages would also conspire against the minister’s deadline. “No matter how one proposes to reconfigure our present hospital network, the A&E queues and waiting lists will continue until such time as our bed capacity is increased.”

The Irish Medical Organisation, which represents NCHDs, said it was concerned about cuts in doctors’ income. “There are a lot of issues to be worked out. We’re not underestimating the task ahead,” said industrial relations officer Fintan Hourihan.

Mr Martin admitted the report represented a challenge, but he said the August 2004 deadline was not negotiable.

More in this section

Lunchtime News

Newsletter

Get a lunch briefing straight to your inbox at noon daily. Also be the first to know with our occasional Breaking News emails.

Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Brand Safety FAQ Help Contact Us Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited