Colman Noctor: Teens need to know that socialising isn't 'cringe'

At a time when we are increasingly concerned about loneliness, perhaps we need to question why we sometimes celebrate behaviours that can lead to social isolation.
"Adolescence has a peculiar contradiction. Just when belonging and peer acceptance become so important, young people can become increasingly reluctant to reveal just how much they want either, and so appearing indifferent can become a form of social self-protection."

"Adolescence has a peculiar contradiction. Just when belonging and peer acceptance become so important, young people can become increasingly reluctant to reveal just how much they want either, and so appearing indifferent can become a form of social self-protection."

I recently had a chat with a group of first-years and decided to talk to them about the value of social connection. I told them to make an effort to get to know others in their year, to talk to them, and to make the most of the opportunities secondary school offers to make new friends.

I thought that was fairly uncontroversial advice, so their reply came as a bit of a surprise.

They explained that being overly friendly, enthusiastic, or eager to make friends was considered “cringe”. Apparently, approaching someone you don’t know and trying to start a conversation can be seen as “trying too hard”. There was a suggestion that appearing indifferent, unimpressed, or generally unbothered was a much more socially desirable position to adopt.

I found that fascinating, albeit a bit concerning.

We spend considerable time discussing the growing problem of loneliness among young people, yet here was a group of students explaining that the very behaviours I was promoting to help alleviate loneliness carried a degree of social embarrassment.

Of course, the fear of appearing too eager is not new. Adolescence has a peculiar contradiction. Just when belonging and peer acceptance become so important, young people can become increasingly reluctant to reveal just how much they want either, and so appearing indifferent can become a form of social self-protection.

However, I wonder whether this contemporary celebration of indifference is making the already complicated task of developing friendships even harder.

When I wondered where the idea that being social was cringe had come from, it wasn’t hard to see how the language young people encounter might shape their views on relationships. Popular phrases such as “protect your peace”, “you don’t need anybody else”, and “cut off anyone who doesn’t add value to your life” are often presented online as empowering messages.

While we can all acknowledge the merit of encouraging young people to set healthy boundaries and recognise genuinely harmful relationships, I worry that these messages can sometimes promote an overly
individualistic view of psychological wellbeing.

Perhaps we shouldn’t be surprised that young people are increasingly reluctant to make social efforts when so much of the messaging they encounter from adults celebrates withdrawal. We have become remarkably comfortable describing ordinary social obligations as emotional burdens, awkward conversations as unnecessary stress, and cancelling plans as self-care. As a result, terms like “my social battery is low” and “I’m overstimulated” have become commonplace in the therapy room.

Yet relationships inevitably involve effort, compromise, and occasional discomfort. If we continually promote the idea that our wellbeing depends on avoiding these experiences, we risk overlooking the psychological benefits of learning to navigate them.

Another casualty of this cultural shift appears to be small talk. I often hear people dismiss it as superficial, meaningless, or even exhausting. I have heard many influential people proudly declare that they “hate small talk” and want only meaningful conversations.

But surely there cannot be ‘Big Talk’ without first engaging in ‘small talk’? How exactly are we supposed to have meaningful conversations without first having the apparently meaningless ones?

Most friendships don’t begin with profound discussions about our deepest fears, ambitions, or emotional vulnerabilities.

For young people, learning to initiate and sustain ordinary conversations is an important developmental achievement. We should encourage them to practice these skills rather than reinforce the idea that ordinary social interaction should be ridiculed.

This becomes particularly important as evenings grow darker and opportunities for spontaneous socialising begin to fade. The freedom of long summer evenings gives way to shorter days, poorer weather and, understandably, more cautious parents. For many teens, opportunities to meet friends become increasingly confined to school, organised activities, and whatever interaction happens on their phones.

We have also spent much of the past decade making everyday life increasingly convenient and contactless. We can order food without speaking to anyone, buy goods without entering a shop, communicate without making a phonecall, and entertain ourselves without leaving the house.

But what makes life more convenient does not necessarily make it more socially fulfilling. Every time we remove a minor social interaction from daily life, we risk losing an opportunity to practise the everyday interpersonal skills that help us navigate the world.

The brief exchange with a shop assistant, the conversation with a neighbour, or the awkward interaction with someone we don’t know might seem inconsequential, yet cumulatively these micro-experiences form the building blocks of our social confidence.

And when we combine this increasingly contactless world with the ever-present alternative of digital entertainment, it becomes remarkably easy to spend considerable periods without any meaningful face-to-face interaction.

Technology can undoubtedly support friendships, but contact is not the same as connection. Sending a Snapchat picture of a wall or your shoe is not the same as spending time together. Face-to-face interaction involves navigating tone, body language, pauses, misunderstandings, and the unpredictability of another person’s responses. It is precisely this unpredictability that makes social interaction challenging, yet developmentally valuable.

We need to become more intentional about creating opportunities for teenagers to spend time together and to pay closer attention to how we model socialisation.

We cannot simply complain that young people spend too much time on their phones while offering no offline alternatives.

We might need to encourage teenagers to invite friends over and acknowledge the joys of a noisy house full of young people.

We also need to recognise that social confidence is not an innate personality trait that some young people possess and others lack. Rather, it is a skill that develops through experience.

When I think about that conversation with first-year students and their suggestion that being friendly might somehow be embarrassing, something about the possibility that young people are suppressing their natural desire to connect for fear of seeming too enthusiastic feels sad. What concerns me is that this apparent celebration of indifference is no longer confined to adolescence. Increasingly, adults seem equally comfortable presenting social withdrawal as a desirable lifestyle choice.

I recognise that being dismissive is often easier than being welcoming. Staying silent is often less risky than starting a conversation, and pretending not to care can feel safer than admitting we want to belong. But genuine social confidence is not about appearing unaffected by others. It is about having the courage to engage with them.

As we move into the winter months, when opportunities for spontaneous connection naturally decline, we should make a conscious effort to foster sociability among our teenagers.

Not by insisting that every young person become extroverted, or by suggesting that solitude is inherently unhealthy, but by ensuring that opportunities for connection remain available, accessible, and socially acceptable, and by modelling these behaviours ourselves.

At a time when we are increasingly concerned about loneliness, perhaps we need to question why we sometimes celebrate behaviours that can lead to social isolation. Because if we want young people to develop meaningful relationships, we need to encourage the ordinary, sometimes awkward and occasionally embarrassing interactions from which those relationships grow.

And perhaps the most important message we can communicate is that there is nothing cringe about being kind, nothing embarrassing about being enthusiastic, and nothing uncool about wanting to connect with another human being.

More in this section

Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Brand Safety FAQ Help Contact Us Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited