Tom Dunne: Jeff Tweedy of Wilco is a giant among modern songwriters

The Belleville star plays Cork and Kilkenny over the next few days 
Jeff Tweedy with Wilco at Cork Opera House during his previous visit to the city, at Sounds From a Safe Harbour. Picture: Bríd O’Donovan

Jeff Tweedy with Wilco at Cork Opera House during his previous visit to the city, at Sounds From a Safe Harbour. Picture: Bríd O’Donovan

Jeff Tweedy, the Wilco front man, plays Live at St. Luke’s this week on his solo Irish tour. If you get to go, savour it and keep your ticket stub in your diary. If you miss it maybe visit the venue in the coming days and pay silent homage to the stage. Generational talent that man, a giant amongst song writers.

How he made it in the music industry is more of a tale of triumph despite record companies rather than because of them. As bad as they are now at spotting or nurturing talent, back then they seemed determined to actually try and stop it developing. “Nip it in the bud before it becomes popular” seemed a likely modus operandi.

It started with Rockville the label Tweedy was with when he was in the alt.country legends — some might say inventors of that genre — Uncle Tupelo. Despite being seminal from the word go, central to No Depression movement and produced for free by REM’s Peter Buck, the label would spend no money on them.

Their lack of interest in the band, lack of belief and apparent unwillingness to help the band develop made me wonder if REM’s Don’t Go Back to Rockville might have been inspired by the band and its label woes. The fact that it was written six years earlier just reinforces my view of REM as visionaries.

Freed from Rockville, Tweedy in his new incarnation, Wilco, signed to Sire Records, where his problems in many ways were just beginning. The debut, A.M. in 1995 did well and 200 dates across America left them firmly established. But as Wilco prepared for the second album, Being There in 1996 things were only hotting up.

It was a double album and Tweedy, concerned for his fan’s wallets, suggested it sell for the price of a single album, which was then $17.98. Incredibly Reprise accepted this suggestion from the impoverished band. By 2003 it was estimated to have cost Wilco over $600,000.

By the time Wilco stepped into Willie Nelson’s studio to record the sublime Summer Teeth things had gone from bad to worse. Reprise were part of Warners and Warners had acquired Time in a deal that saddled them with $16 billion in debt. The upshot of this debt was that Warner wanted more obvious singles from Wilco.

Wilco succumbed to the pressure. Can’t Stand It, as radio friendly a song as they could muster was produced. It didn’t really do the business. It left both parties damaged and it overshadowed an album that truly, for me, announced Wilco on the world stage.

It was at this point that I first got to interview Tweedy. I was blissfully unaware of the record company shenanigans. I thought he sounded dejected in the interview which I found odd. She’s a Jar and A Shot in the Arm I was playing off the radio. It was Album of the Year material.

That the next album, Yankee Hotel Foxtrot was as close to a modern classic as you can get came as no surprise to me. The direction of travel towards I am Trying to Break Your Heart, Jesus Etc, Heavy Metal Drummer and Ashes of American Flags — stunning songs all — was evidenced on Summer Teeth. How could Warner not have known?

But they didn’t. Wilco were dropped before the album was released. Luckily the band managed to get the rights to release the album themselves. It's worth noting that Warner heard the tracks on that album and still dropped them.

Incredibly too they opted to put the resources they had earmarked for Wilco into the Flaming Lips instead. They say that in the years that followed Warner saw the error of their ways and vowed never to treat any band again as badly as they treated Wilco. It was win-win for the Flaming Lips.

Needless to say, on its release Yankee Hotel Foxtrot was an instant success. It has since sold over 600,000 copies, won a Grammy and is their most successful album to date. Wilco are now established as one of America’s coolest, most successful bands. Their back catalogue is simply wonderful.

But it is Tweedy that fascinates me. He is very much a singer songwriter in the 21st-century mould. When he is not with Wilco he is writing wonderful books on songwriting, collaborating with others or writing and touring solo albums. For that is the lot of the modern songwriter, even one as incredibly gifted as Jeff Tweedy.

  • Jeff Tweedy's remaining Irish shows are St Luke's, Cork, Thursday, November 19; and St Canice's Cathedral, Kilkenny, Friday, November 20

More in this section

Scene & Heard

Newsletter

From music and film to books and visual art, explore the best of culture in Munster and beyond. Selected by our Arts Editor and delivered weekly.

Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Brand Safety FAQ Help Contact Us Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited