Expert: Tuam DNA tests can be used at mother and baby home

A genetics expert said modern forensics could be used to test for DNA at the Tuam mother and baby home site.

A report by the expert technical group on the site said the cost of DNA testing could be an issue when it comes to examining any remains.

Last week, Minister for Children Katherine Zappone aired other concerns such as how extracting DNA can damage remains.

However, professor of population genetics at Trinity College Dublin (TCD), Dan Bradley — considered the country’s leading expert — said it was possible to test for DNA there.

“With samples, we’ve worked on there was no way we can work out a meaningful relative, but these [the Tuam] samples are different.

“Modern technologies are very powerful for working with these samples. The cost is thousands, it’s not millions. But is it possible? It could be, from what I know,” said Prof Bradley.

His lab has worked on several hundred human and animal specimens and while accepting “you can never predict the outcome”, he said the success rate in Ireland, for extracting DNA, is quite high.

“The only way to know if you’ll get DNA is to test it. We’ve tested samples and got nothing. Generally speaking in Ireland, with samples, we’ve had a success rate of three out of four,” said Prof Bradley.

The report by the Tuam technical group also said the best samples for DNA purposes were from teeth which were not adequately developed in children under the age of two.

However, Prof Bradley said there is a better bone from which to extract DNA.

“The best bone to use is the petrous bone which contains the inner ear and is attached to the skull. This can work with children. Teeth are also good for DNA but the petrous bone is five times better,” he said.

Speaking specifically about the cost of DNA testing, which is now done through what is known as next-generation sequencing, the expert said the expense has dropped considerably since it was first developed.

“Before 2000, the first human genome was sequenced for approximately €200m and it took years. Now a human genome can be sequenced for, say, thousands of euro and in a couple of months,” said the professor.

Two years ago, Prof Bradley and colleagues at TCD and Queen’s University Belfast, published research after sequencing the first genomes from ancient Irish people. One of them was a 5,200-year-old farming woman.

“We have research projects here in our lab where we have got whole genomes from specimens that go back 10,000 years. So it is possible to extract DNA going back a century,” said Prof Bradley.

However, when it comes to Tuam, he said there are factors other than the age of bones that matter.

The chemistry of the soil has an effect on the bones. Whether the soil is water-logged is another factor.

David MacHugh, professor of genomics at UCD, has also spoken about Tuam.

“I am perplexed by the hesitancy in applying modern forensic genomics to genetic identification of the skeletal material found at the Tuam mother and baby home,” he wrote in a letter in the Irish Times yesterday.

More on this topic

Failure to publish survivors report criticisedFailure to publish survivors report criticised

Zappone rejects criticism over report’s releaseZappone rejects criticism over report’s release

Staff denounce 'run and grab-all by nuns' as centre for vulnerable in Cork set to closeStaff denounce 'run and grab-all by nuns' as centre for vulnerable in Cork set to close

DNA samples from Tuam Mother and Baby Home survivors can be taken without new legislationDNA samples from Tuam Mother and Baby Home survivors can be taken without new legislation


The Cosmetify Index reveals the cosmetics companies that are generating the most buzz online – and Dubai-based Huda Kattan has the top spot.Huda Beauty tops the 10 ‘most popular’ beauty brands this year

Read the script of Kya deLongchamps’ kitchen-sink drama to set the scene to make an informed choice when selecting this home essentialTake the plunge: Read this checklist before you splash out on your new kitchen sink

SOMETIMES, the journey is more important than the destination. And sometimes, we just want to sit at home eating a bag of jelly beans, while thinking about more jelly beans. Life is only as significant or special as we make it.GameTech: Death Stranding is a divisive, beautiful journey packaged in a cool world

Former Oasis drummer Tony McCarroll tells Richard Purden about the mad times when five Manc-Irish lads became one of the biggest rock bands in the worldNot looking back in anger: Former Oasis drummer looks back at the mad times of one of the biggest rock bands in the world

More From The Irish Examiner