'Stuck for weeks' worst-case outlook as Suez tanker hits oil and Europe's factories

Team whose CV includes salvaging the Kursk nuclear submarine says freeing the ship in Egypt is one of their trickiest missions yet
'Stuck for weeks' worst-case outlook as Suez tanker hits oil and Europe's factories

Stranded container ship Ever Given is seen after it ran aground in the Suez Canal, Egypt. 

The Dutch emergency response team hired to free the vast ship blocking the Suez canal has pulled off some dramatic recoveries, including lifting Russia's Kursk nuclear submarine from the Barents Sea floor, but says the current mission in Egypt is one of the trickiest it has faced.

Weighing 200,000 tonnes without cargo, the Ever Given is the heaviest vessel that Smit Salvage, a subsidiary of the Dutch marine services company Boskalis contracted in the rescue, has faced in its nearly 180-year history.

With real-time emergency response crews across the globe, Smit Salvage has helped recover or salvage dozens of wrecks and free stranded cargo ships, ferries and tankers.

Vast economic interests

While lives are not at stake this time, the vast economic interests in one of the world's busiest shipping lanes make the urgency of the situation critical.

The fallout has been immediate: Oil prices rose, and there are warnings that the blockage has added more pressure to global supply chains from Asia to Europe already strained by the Covid-19 pandemic.

Asian factories have for decades been the suppliers of most valuable consumer items bought in Europe and global trade runs on very short delivery times.

During the pandemic, demand from European households has increased again and the prospects of having to take the long route around Africa would disrupt global manufacturing.                                

Factories relying on JIT will worry most

Moody's vice president Daniel Harlid said European factories — in particular, car and parts manufacturers that rely on “just-in-time” supply chains with no stockpiles — will likely be worrying most. 

"Even if the situation is resolved within the next 48 hours, port congestion and further delays to an already constrained supply chain is inevitable," Mr Haild said. 

The cost of freight which has been driven up during the Covid crisis in the past year "will also most likely increase or at least stop decreasing from their currently very high levels”, he said. 

Meanwhile, Boskalis chief executive Peter Berdowski, who has compared the operation to saving a beached whale, will need to come up with a plan that is acceptable to the shipowner, insurance companies, and the Egyptian, state-owned Suez Canal authority.

A difficult puzzle 

The Ever Given has grounded at both ends, and initial attempts to shift it with tugs showed it would not budge easily from its position wedged diagonally across a narrow stretch of the canal.

"It is a difficult puzzle, because the ship is currently being strained by unnatural forces. We don't want it to tip or tear in half during the salvage," he said.

Experts are divided on how much of a help the narrow window of a spring tide in coming days will be in efforts to refloat the vessel, which can carry up to 20,000 containers.

Clemens Schapeler with global logistics platform Transporeon said: "I think the most likely outcome is that it will be refloated on Sunday or Monday. But the worst-case (stuck for weeks) is a real possibility."

Dredging difficulties

The Suez Canal authority is mobilising dredging vessels to remove underwater sand or other material beneath the bow and stern ends.  The hardness of that material and the ability to position the dredging vessels effectively will determine how quickly that operation goes.

A core team from the Netherlands boarded the ship on Thursday and collected initial readings and is calculating the best options. Officials involved in the operation told Reuters the most obvious first step will be to remove large fuel and ballast to lighten the vessel, in combination with dredging away sand and to then attempt to pull it afloat.

If those initial measures fail and the ship remains stuck, it will need to have its cargo of several thousand shipping containers removed in a job that officials warned could take weeks.

Costa Concordia mission

In 2012, Mr Smit and Italy's Tito Neri removed bunker fuel from the cruise vessel Costa Concordia, which had been carrying over 4,000 passengers and crew when it hit a rock and encountered stability problems while passing Tuscany's Isle of Giglio.

“Time is the deciding factor here. The ship itself is undamaged, but there is massive consequential damage from the blockade,” said Mr Berdowski, chief executive of Boskalis. 

• Reuters and Irish Examiner

 

x

More in this section

The Business Hub

Newsletter

News and analysis on business, money and jobs from Munster and beyond by our expert team of business writers.

Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Brand Safety FAQ Help Contact Us Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited