'Unacceptable' CervicalCheck report leaked to media before women received their results

'Unacceptable' CervicalCheck report leaked to media before women received their results

After a year of “moving the goalposts” on the publication of the CervicalCheck review, it is "unacceptable” parts of the report were leaked to the media before the women involved had their results, Labour has claimed.

It is reported the review led by the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists in Britain is found a large number of previously missed abnormalities after re-examining the slides of over 1,000 women.

The women were tested for the disease under CervicalCheck and given the all-clear but later developed cancer. It is believed that the review found some cancers that could have been prevented.

“After over a year of moving the goalposts on the date of the publication of the RCOG report, it is unacceptable to see parts of this report leaked without all women who are included in the review being told of the findings,” said Alan Kelly, the party's health spokesperson.

Mr Kelly asked how the Minister for Health, Simon Harris, could justify the leak that came from either his department or the HSE?

If one was being suspicious about this leak you could think that some people wanted to manage out how this information initially got into the public domain. If so that would be disgraceful.

A spokesperson for the Department of Health said a "core principle" underpinning the review process had been to ensure that the women would have an opportunity to receive their results before the publication of the expert panel's aggregate report.

“In keeping with this principle, the Minister for Health will only receive the aggregate report when he has been assured that all women or next-of-kin have had the opportunity to receive their individual report."

Taoiseach, Leo Varakdar, said it was wrong that details of the review had been leaked to the media before all of the women were told about their results and offered meetings. He said some have accepted meetings and others had been happy to receive the information in writing.

“We agreed this report would not be published and would not be made available until each of those women had the opportunity to have that meeting first because they are the ones who should hear it first,” Mr Varadkar told the Dáil.

“We do not have the report and it will not be published until every woman has had the chance to hear about her own results and to have a meeting if she wants one. Once that has been done, it will go to the Minister for Health and then it will be published. At that point, a briefing will be provided for the Opposition parties."

Sinn Féin health spokesperson, Louise O'Reilly, said the “drip-feed” of information in the media was not fair on the women involved.

“If these sources are to be believed, it is possible that a significant number of women screened under the CervicalCheck programme were told that they did not need a follow-up smear test but later developed cancer,” she said.

CervicalCheck campaigner, Stephen Teap, said they would not be making any comment on the review while the women and their families were receiving the results. Mr Teap said the remaining women should have their results by the weekend

More on this topic

'I understand the anger': Consultant says CervicalCheck staff being subjected to 'damaging' abuse'I understand the anger': Consultant says CervicalCheck staff being subjected to 'damaging' abuse

Vicky Phelan backs Lorraine Walsh's decision to quit CervicalCheck committeeVicky Phelan backs Lorraine Walsh's decision to quit CervicalCheck committee

Taoiseach open to new smear test reviewTaoiseach open to new smear test review

'Mass distrust': Cervical Check losing staff due to stress'Mass distrust': Cervical Check losing staff due to stress


More in this Section

Vets point to 'copper deficiency' as cause of condition impacting Killarney's unique Red deerVets point to 'copper deficiency' as cause of condition impacting Killarney's unique Red deer

Ireland needs to increase efforts as environment is at 'tipping point'- reportIreland needs to increase efforts as environment is at 'tipping point'- report

Five arrested, 232 money mules identified in laundering investigationFive arrested, 232 money mules identified in laundering investigation

School principal breaks down in tears after winning case over dismissal decision School principal breaks down in tears after winning case over dismissal decision


Lifestyle

Kya deLongchamps wonders if we should surrender to the pagan prompting of mistletoe.Mistletoe is returning to its hemiparasitic life back in the woodland

Playing games will sneak in physical activity without them even realising.9 fun ways to get your kids to do more exercise

It all began with a Christmas special 30 years ago this month. Chris Wasser pays tribute to The Simpsons.The Simpsons is 30 years old - and it all began with a Christmas special

The bug causes vomiting and diarrhoea and can leave people feeling weak.Tips to help stop the spread of the dreaded norovirus

More From The Irish Examiner