UCC win appeal over requirement to disclose details of loan agreement to RTÉ

UCC win appeal over requirement to disclose details of loan agreement to RTÉ

A High Court judge has overturned the Information Commissioner's decision requiring University College Cork to disclose to RTÉ certain information about a €100m loan agreement between the college and the European Investment Bank.

The Commissioner must now reconsider RTÉ's request, made under the Freedom of Information Act, in line with Mr Justice Garrett Simons' findings.

A core finding was that the Commissioner made a material error in law in taking as his starting point a presumption "in favour" of disclosure which required UCC to "justify" its refusal of access to the information.

The Commissioner also made a material error in interpreting the "competitive prejudice" exemption from disclosure set out in the Act, the judge held.

The material sought was "self-evidently commercially sensitive" and the Commissioner appeared to have expected UCC to have demonstrated some additional justification for not disclosing it, he said.

The Commissioner's conclusion UCC would not be harmed by disclosure of the material was "unsustainable".

Having sought the views of the EIB, which supported UCC's objections to disclosure, the Commissioner was obliged to have regard to them, he added.

UCC had objected to disclosing the information on grounds that could prejudice the competitive position of the university.

The judge noted the information relates to existing credit facilities between UCC and other financial institutions, the rate of interest payable under the loan agreement executed in July 2016 with the EIB, and certain financial covenants to be observed by UCC as borrower.

A striking feature of this case was "how little" information UCC was seeking to exempt from disclosure, he said.

The finance contract ran for 50 typed pages and the information UCC wished not to disclose, including the interest rate, ran to about 20 lines.

UCC appealed to the High Court, under section 24 of the Act, after the Commissioner upheld RTÉ's challenge to the refusal.

In his judgment today, Mr Justice Simons stressed an appeal under section 24 is on a point of law, not the merits, and UCC must show there was an error of law on the Commissioner's part.

He was satisfied the Commissioner's decision involved a number of material errors of law, in particular in mistakenly taking as its starting point a presumption in favour of disclosure which required UCC to justify refusing access.

A second material error was that the Commissioner misinterpreted and/or misapplied the threshold for the "competitive prejudice" exemption from disclosure in section 26.1.b of the FOI Act.

While UCC had initially objected to disclosing the finance contract or loan agreement in its entirety, it had in the appeal not objected to the disclosure of a redacted form of the finance contract as provided by the EIB to the Commissioner in late 2017, he noted.

Because the full unredacted version of the loan agreement was made available to the court for the purpose of the appeal, he had been able to compare and contrast that with the redacted version, he said.

The full version was also available to the Commissioner who failed to have proper regard to certain material in it in reaching the impugned decision, he said.

More on this topic

Retrial ordered in sex assault case as juror related to man’s victimRetrial ordered in sex assault case as juror related to man’s victim

Gardaí called in after judge hears father strips and flogs his three children twice weeklyGardaí called in after judge hears father strips and flogs his three children twice weekly

Interim examiner appointed to the Irish-headquartered parent of Apple reseller Compu bInterim examiner appointed to the Irish-headquartered parent of Apple reseller Compu b

Full hearing cleared relating to jailed US fraudster Bernie Madoff's Ponzi schemeFull hearing cleared relating to jailed US fraudster Bernie Madoff's Ponzi scheme

More in this Section

Gardaí seek help finding woman, 22, missing for over two weeksGardaí seek help finding woman, 22, missing for over two weeks

Person in garda custody rushed to Cork hospital with suspected heroin overdosePerson in garda custody rushed to Cork hospital with suspected heroin overdose

Places of worship allowed to have over 50 people according to new guidelinesPlaces of worship allowed to have over 50 people according to new guidelines

The EuroMillions numbers are in...The EuroMillions numbers are in...


Lifestyle

All eyes are on America for Independence Day - so what happens when the country's borders reopen again? Tom Breathnach gets the lowdownAltered States: What will tourism in the US look like after lockdown?

From days by the seaside to adrenaline-filled days riding rollercoasters, Leinster offers staycationers major bang for their buck.Staycations 2020: Leinster, where Eastern promises are delivered in full

Des O'Sullivan previews the diverse items that will spark interest among collectorsAntiques: From a sword to crystal chandeliers and a dictionary

Kya deLongchamps strikes up the band for some lesser copied American mid-century talentIt's July 4 so let's strike up the band for American designs

More From The Irish Examiner