TDs reject ‘means-test’ for access to abortion

Attempts to ban public funding for abortions could lead to means testing for those seeking terminations and discrimination against impoverished women, TDs have warned.

The comments came as the Dáil continued to debate the passage of legislation to enact the Yes vote to grant women access to abortions.

Independent TD Carol Nolan had moved a motion in report stage to stop public funds being used for terminations.

Carol Nolan

Several TDs said the move went against the outcome of the referendum and would lead to a two-tier health system for women in Ireland.

Fianna Fáil’s Billy Kelleher said the motion amounted to “means testing” for women in need of an abortion, while Solidarity-People Before Profit TD Brid Smith said the proposal was not “logical, equal, or fair” and would only allow rich women access abortion.

Ms Nolan said taxpayers were being asked to pay for “killing” while Independents Mattie McGrath and Peadar Tóibín backed her motion.

Lisa Chambers of Fianna Fáil warned that, without public funding for terminations, women would be forced to remain pregnant against their will.

Citizens did not vote for inequality or to erect barriers to the most impoverished in society, said the Mayo TD.

Jonathan O’Brien of Sinn Féin said it was “rubbish” to say that if no public funds went on abortions, more money would be available for other health services.

He said the World Health Organisation had found that 7m women are admitted to hospitals worldwide every year due to unsafe abortions.

Health Minister Simon Harris said the intention was to make abortion “free and safe” in Ireland and not to divide people.

Related Articles

Abortion hospitals lacked staff and resources

Medical professions raise concern about preparedness of abortion services

Readers blog: Repeal side quick to call for sanctions now they are gamekeeper

Economist defends position as tweet on planned abortion in Drogheda described by Minister as 'pretty darn despicable'

More in this Section

Man arrested after masked raider threatens Cork home owner with knife

Calls for expert group to examine nurses pay claims

Bertie Ahern: Theresa May needs to 'swallow humble pie'

Man charged with burglary in Cork, teen arrested after hospital burglary in Kerry


Take a look inside the rockstar-themed rooms on Virgin’s new cruise ship

Set to be a bridesmaid or a groomsman this year? Here’s your ultimate wedding party checklist!

As Kate Moss turns 45, here are 7 style lessons we’ve learned from her

New series explores Ireland's remote townlands and its people

More From The Irish Examiner