Naughton recuses herself from ‘vote-gate’ probe after admitting voting for colleagues

Naughton recuses herself from ‘vote-gate’ probe after admitting voting for colleagues
Leo Varadkar with Hildegarde Naughton, chair of the Members’ Interests Committee

A Government TD has recused herself from the investigation into voting irregularities in the Dáil after admitting she did the same thing.

Hildegarde Naughton, chair of the Members’ Interests Committee, released a statement on Wednesday saying that she would not be able to take part the investigation into the controversy, as she too had voted for colleagues in the Dail on “less than a handful of occasions”.

The issue emerged after it was revealed in media reporting that Fianna Fail TD Timmy Dooley’s vote was recorded on six occasions despite his absence from the chamber.

An inquiry into Dail voting last week, which was fuelled by further revelations that votes had been cast by more Fianna Fail TDs who were not present in the chamber at the time of the ballot, recommended that no disciplinary action should be taken against offending representatives, but a wider review of the voting system is needed.

In the time since, more TDs have admitted in taking part in the practice, however stating they only did so when their colleague was in the chamber.

“The Taoiseach, the Leader of the Opposition and many other members of Dail Eireann have voted for a colleague while asked to do so while that colleague was in the chamber.

“So have I, on less than a handful of occasions.

“I have never voted for someone who was not present in the chamber,” Ms Naughton’s statement read.

Ms Naughton says legal advice she has received by the Parliamentary Legal Adviser, indicates recusing herself from the investigation would be the preferable option in relation to balance, but will continue to remain as chair of the Committee on Members Interests.

“The legal advice now received indicates that anyone who voted for a fellow TD while they were both in the chamber would be advised to consider whether the process would be best served by them not adjudicating on these present complaints,” she said.

“The present investigation concerns voting for members who were outside the chamber and the two are in no way comparable.

“That is accepted across the political divide, notwithstanding those trying to muddy the waters.

“However, I have made the decision to recuse myself to ensure that no possible perception of bias exists and to ensure that the committee can investigate this matter without delay and free from challenge.

“Now is the time to do so – prior to the committee commencing its work.

“While the advice I received indicates that any challenge to my role would be unlikely to be successful, I am motivated by an abundance of caution.

“While the decision is not made lightly, it is one I am making to ensure the integrity of the process.

“It is vital that there is not even the slightest perception of bias in the proceedings of the Committee.”

The fallout since the revelations has caused much political debate and disharmony between the two main parties, within the Dail chamber, and in the media, at one point sparking rumours of a potential snap election.

Fianna Fáil leader Micheál Martin
Fianna Fáil leader Micheál Martin

Fianna Fáil leader Micheál Martin, who apologised in the Dail on behalf of his party members, went on to criticise “the behaviour, motivation and record of many who clearly have no interest in dealing with this matter with any balance.

“Fine Gael’s claim to be outraged has been more than a bit undermined by the sound of laughter and backslapping coming from their corridors together with daily briefings about immediately holding an election they claim not to want until next spring,” Mr Martin added.

More on this topic

Committee recommends Fianna Fáil TD be reprimanded for voting for colleague in DáilCommittee recommends Fianna Fáil TD be reprimanded for voting for colleague in Dáil

Fianna Fáil TD Barry Cowen cleared of any wrongdoing over 'votegate'Fianna Fáil TD Barry Cowen cleared of any wrongdoing over 'votegate'

TDs agree to independent examination of parliament attendance and expenses after controversiesTDs agree to independent examination of parliament attendance and expenses after controversies

Healy-Rae declines to comment on report he was attending funeral while signed into DáilHealy-Rae declines to comment on report he was attending funeral while signed into Dáil


More in this Section

Gardaí say no reports of cars ramming on the northside despite videoGardaí say no reports of cars ramming on the northside despite video

Over 600 people waiting on hospital trolleysOver 600 people waiting on hospital trolleys

€18,000 of suspected counterfeit goods seized in Tipperary€18,000 of suspected counterfeit goods seized in Tipperary

Varadkar congratulates Johnson on 'enormous victory'Varadkar congratulates Johnson on 'enormous victory'


Lifestyle

Unique drawings by Quentin Blake, one of Britain’s best-loved illustrators, are available at a Christie’s online auction which runs until December 17.Your chance to buy drawings by Roald Dahl illustrator Quentin Blake

Ciara McDonnell talks to four high-profile people about their festive traditions and favourite tracksHere's what has these famous faces rockin’ around the Christmas tree

More From The Irish Examiner