Man makes claim of 'electoral fraud' in High Court case against abortion referendum result

Man makes claim of 'electoral fraud' in High Court case against abortion referendum result

By Ann O'Loughlin

A man seeking leave to challenge the result of the abortion referendum has claimed the Taoiseach and Minister for Health had made “misleading” statements which “duped” some people into voting Yes and “materially affected” the outcome.

Charles Byrne claims Taoiseach Leo Varadkar and Minister for Health Simon Harris were not permitted under the Constitution to advocate for a Yes vote and made statements which impermissibly interfered with the conduct of the referendum.

The Constitution did not permit the government to advocate against the right to life of the unborn in the Eighth amendment, Geoffrey Sumner BL, for Mr Byrne, told the president of the High Court.

When Mr Justice Peter Kelly asked was counsel arguing that the government, having proposed repeal, had to remain “mute", counsel said they were not entitled to advocate against the right to life of the unborn.

Certain statements by both politicians misled and misinformed voters and questioned the credibility of those opposed to repeal, Mr Sumner argued. That included a statement by the Taoiseach to the effect the only way to permit abortion for life-limiting conditions was by repeal, he said.

Leo Varadkar and Simon Harris.
Leo Varadkar and Simon Harris.

Counsel also argued the Referendum Commission was obliged, but had failed, to fully and properly explain in “ordinary language” the “far-reaching” legal impact of a Yes vote.

He was not suggesting any bad faith by the Commission but rather it had not met its statutory obligations and its obligations to act in line with the McKenna principles for referendum campaigns, he said.

Mr Justice Kelly is hearing an application by Mr Byrne, a piano teacher and musician from College Rise, Drogheda, Co Louth, for leave to bring a petition challenging the referendum outcome.

The hearing continues tomorrow.

A separate application by Joanna Jordan, a homemaker, from Upper Glenageary Road, Dun Laoghaire, will be heard after Mr Byrne’s application concludes.

The Referendum Act requires, before a petition can be brought, an intended petitioner must show prima facie evidence of matters likely to "materially" affect the referendum outcome.

On May 25th, 1,429,981 people voted to repeal the Eighth Amendment. 723,632 voted against.

Mr Byrne contends he has evidence of irregularities in the conduct of the referendum entitling him to leave to bring a petition. He claims persons were excluded from the register; two polling cards were issued to the same person; persons permanently living abroad voted when, he claims, they were not entitled to do so and that excess numbers of people, up to 500,000, were registered.

He also claims volunteer tallies suggested turnout figures in some locations of more than 100%.

Kenneth Fogarty SC, also for Mr Byrne, said they had some evidence of “worrying irregularities” and "electoral fraud" in the conduct of the referendum, had photos of student voters in UCD and would call evidence of “precisely what went on there”.

His side needed more time to assemble such evidence and the court should take into account a citizen seeking to assemble evidence to dispute a referendum result has considerably less resources than the State, he said.

This was a referendum about “life and death changes” and information affecting the integrity of the electoral process should be made available by the State, he argued.

The State maintains Mr Byrne has not produced any prima facie evidence to support his claims and Frank Callanan SC, for the State, and Eoin McCullough SC, for the Referendum Commission, opposed any more time being granted.

Mr Callanan said there was no onus on the State to assist Mr Byrne in assembling evidence and the people are entitled to certainty about the referendum result.

Mr Justice Kelly will rule on Wednesday whether to grant Mr Byrne more time as sought.

A third application for leave to bring a petition which was initiated by Ciarán Tracey, a retired public servant from Leitrim village, was withdrawn today on terms including agreement by the State parties not to pursue him for legal costs.

The judge refused an application by another Co Leitrim man, Diarmaid McConville, from Dromahair, to be substituted for Mr Tracey in his application after finding there was no procedure for permitting such a substitution. Mr McConville has said he intended to appeal the refusal to the Supreme Court.

More on this topic

Man reversed into junction on wrong side of roadMan reversed into junction on wrong side of road

Oberstown is next for boy if he gets into ‘one more scrap’Oberstown is next for boy if he gets into ‘one more scrap’

Cork man claims man 'laughing away' during court hearing gifted him cash seized during Garda raidCork man claims man 'laughing away' during court hearing gifted him cash seized during Garda raid

Murder accused 'wouldn’t be in current situation' had she not been abused as child, court hearsMurder accused 'wouldn’t be in current situation' had she not been abused as child, court hears

More in this Section

Murder accused 'wouldn’t be in current situation' had she not been abused as child, court hearsMurder accused 'wouldn’t be in current situation' had she not been abused as child, court hears

Boy, 17, missing in DublinBoy, 17, missing in Dublin

'Those cows would have been coming to me” - Cork farmer claiming €1.6m in damages"Those cows would have been coming to me” - Cork farmer claiming €1.6m in damages

'We'd prefer to be working' - Ambulance staff begin second day of strike over union recognition'We'd prefer to be working' - Ambulance staff begin second day of strike over union recognition


Lifestyle

Garbage offered a pop twist on grunge’s maximalist angst when they materialised in a dramatic swirl in the mid-Nineties. Like a candy-cane Nirvana, they were bleak and baroque but with tunes you could hum in the dark.Garbage's return to Dublin well worth the wait

Circle back to fashion's hottest retro print, says Annmarie O'Connor.Trend of the Week: Circling back to fashion's hottest retro print

Ever wondered what it would be like to move lock, stock and barrel into a tiny home, like the ones on Netflix’s Tiny House Nation?Are you ready to join the tiny-house movement?

Kya deLongchamps reports back on the performance of her photovoltaic array and wonders if it could handle the addition of an electric carDIY: Get ready for a natural high

More From The Irish Examiner