Judge orders hospital detention of 'extraordinarily vulnerable' man for urgent colonoscopy against his wishes

Judge orders hospital detention of 'extraordinarily vulnerable' man for urgent colonoscopy against his wishes

A hospital can detain an "extraordinarily vulnerable" man with suspected bowel cancer for the purpose of performing an urgent colonoscopy on him against his wishes, the High Court has ordered.

The president of the High Court, Mr Justice Peter Kelly, was told the man refuses to accept his illness or that he requires a colonoscopy and doctors believe he lacks capacity to appreciate how serious his condition is.

Aged in his 40s, the man's father died after undergoing surgery for bowel cancer and that "unfortunate experience" has probably influenced the man's thinking, the judge said.

On the basis of medical evidence, the judge today granted Maireád McKenna, for the HSE, orders permitting the man's detention in hospital for the purpose of performing a colonoscopy.

The orders were made in the context of a petition to have the man made a ward of court and based on the view of two doctors the man lacks capacity to make decisions on his treatment.

The judge directed a further capacity assessment on the man be done by a court appointed medical visitor and returned the matter to next week when he will be told the results of the colonoscopy.

In his ruling, the judge noted the man, from a non-EU country, has lived here for a considerable time and is a "very good worker".

Having noticed blood in his stools for a considerable period, and feeling weak and tired, the man had gone last month to the hospital's emergency department where he was triaged and a nurse noted he was unwell, pale and dehydrated.

A blood test revealed his haemoglobin was critically low and he was transfused with several blood units.

A CT scan showed a large mass in his colon area which immediately raised the possibility of surgical intervention and a consultant surgeon took over his care.

The judge said the evidence is that a colonoscopy is necessary, not just because of the man's symptoms but also because his father had previously been diagnosed with bowel cancer and died after surgery.

It was considered the man would require surgery but he had declined to be involved in any of the procedures doctors wish to perform.

The surgeon shared the view of a consultant psychiatrist the man lacks capacity to consent to treatment and has a psychotic disorder, the judge noted.

As well as the concerns about capacity, there were also concerns the man might leave the hospital, he said.

This man is "extraordinarily vulnerable" with fluctuating haemoglobin levels, low body weight and is very weak and the medical view is that treatment is in his best interests, he said.

Given the evidence on capacity, and the fact of a petition to have the man made a ward of court, the judge said he would direct a wardship inquiry.

In the interim, he was satisfied it was in the man's best interests that a colonoscopy, "at least", should be done to get the necessary tissue for a histological diagnosis of the tumour and he would make the orders sought.

Any decision on surgery will be considered later.

More on this topic

Appeal court allows receiver to repossess Capel Street building which housed former theatre and showroomAppeal court allows receiver to repossess Capel Street building which housed former theatre and showroom

Drunk driver who spat in Garda's face after 'long night' fined and given four-year driving banDrunk driver who spat in Garda's face after 'long night' fined and given four-year driving ban

Paul Gascoigne cleared of sex assault but jury still considering beating chargePaul Gascoigne cleared of sex assault but jury still considering beating charge

Couple who stopped making mortgage repayments on family home five years ago lose bid to overturn possessionCouple who stopped making mortgage repayments on family home five years ago lose bid to overturn possession


More in this Section

€70,000 worth of heroin seized at Dublin Airport€70,000 worth of heroin seized at Dublin Airport

Girl, 12, who suffered migraines years after wheelchair lift struck her car headrest in accident is awarded €60kGirl, 12, who suffered migraines years after wheelchair lift struck her car headrest in accident is awarded €60k

'He climbed on top of me while I was driving' - Taxi driver talks about how she was assaulted by four men'He climbed on top of me while I was driving' - Taxi driver talks about how she was assaulted by four men

Fine Gael to promise tax cuts as part of next election campaignFine Gael to promise tax cuts as part of next election campaign


Lifestyle

I go for a quick run with Jasper the dog (he runs, I walk)Working Life: Margaret Naughton - Jack and Jill Children’s Foundation

We had our first filling last weekend.Learner Dad: As long as other people gave their kids more sugar than we gave ours, we assumed we didn’t have a problem

Experts on bedroom style reveal their top tips to Gabrielle Fagan, so you can create your perfect sleeping space.Let’s go to bed: How to create the cosy winter retreat you’ve always dreamed of

Sink your teeth into our top tips for Halloween dental care.Dental shock: Save your child's teeth from the ‘horrors’ of Halloween

More From The Irish Examiner