Case against State, Denis O'Brien and Michael Lowry will not go ahead, court rules

Case against State, Denis O'Brien and Michael Lowry will not go ahead, court rules
Denis O'Brien

A High Court judge has refused to allow an English company to fund a legal action against the State, businessman Denis O'Brien and former Government Minister Michael Lowry.

The decision, based on a law that dates back to 1634, means that the case will not go ahead as the plaintiff does not have enough money to pay the legal fees.

Ms Justice Aileen Donnelly said today that third-party funding in such cases is illegal under Irish law.

The plaintiff, James Boyle of Persona Digital Telephony, said he does not have the €10m needed, and will therefore have to drop the case.

Mr Boyle had sought to take a case after his company lost out on a mobile phone licence that was issued to Denis O'Brien's Esat Digifone consortium in 1996.

He claimed that Esat won the competition by bribing the then Minister for Communications Michael Lowry - which is denied.

While third-party funding of legal cases is common in Britain, it is banned in Ireland under the ancient law of 'champerty'.

It states that no third party should be allowed to fund a legal case in the hope that they will take a share of any financial award.

The law is believed to date back to Roman times and became part of Irish law during British rule when the Maintenance and Embracery Act was passed in 1634.

This case was the first time that a direct challenge has been made to the law in an Irish court.

In her judgment, Justice Donnelly said that she had considered arguments made by Persona's legal team that the constitutional right to access to the courts should supersede an ancient law that had been abandoned in Britain and elsewhere.

She said that she accepted an affidavit filed by Mr Boyle in which he said that he is "nowhere near the estimated €10m required to finance the proposed litigation".

She said that Mr Boyle had confirmed that if the funding arrangement is not approved, he will have no other means of prosecuting the case.

She added that Persona's legal team had said their claim is "of great public importance" and that if she allowed the funding arrangement she would ensure "the constitutional guarantee of access to justice".

But citing numerous judgments by Irish courts upholding the law of champerty, she said third party funding arrangements, "cannot be viewed as being consistent with public policy in this jurisdiction".

She said third-party funding remains a civil wrong and a criminal offence in Ireland, regardless of changes in attitude to similar arrangements in Britain or elsewhere.

She also pointed out that Persona had not challenged the constitutionality of the law and that the Superior Courts of Ireland have upheld the elements of champerty.

Justice Donnelly further noted that the legislature upheld the law on champerty in 2007 when it held a review of ancient laws and disposed of some of them.

Citing a previous judgment from 2011, she wrote: "In Ireland it is unlawful for a party without an interest to fund the litigation of another at all and, in particular, it is unlawful to fund litigation in return for a share of the proceeds."

At a brief hearing she concluded: "In the circumstances, I refuse the relief sought by the plaintiffs."

More in this Section

More than 500 patients waiting for beds in Irish hospitals More than 500 patients waiting for beds in Irish hospitals

Gardaí resume questioning of man, 28, in relation to attempted ATM theft in CavanGardaí resume questioning of man, 28, in relation to attempted ATM theft in Cavan

Brexit and the backstop: Key questions about Boris Johnson’s letter to Donald TuskBrexit and the backstop: Key questions about Boris Johnson’s letter to Donald Tusk

Average of 129 motorists have cars clamped in Dublin every dayAverage of 129 motorists have cars clamped in Dublin every day


Lifestyle

It’s 100% better than takeout.How to make Jamie Oliver’s veggie pad thai

The Hunger is billed as an opera, but its composer, Donnacha Dennehy, prefers to call it a “docu-cantata”.The Hunger: Appeals to God and for pity in this clash of two linguistic worlds

We take a trip down memory lane and check out what happened on this day in years gone by by looking back at some Irish Examiner front pages and highlighting other events which went down in history across the world.August 21, 2019: A look back at what happened on this day in years gone by

For this year’s sausage survey we focused on a high proportion of meat. It had to be over 65% — a substantial sausage that would barbecue well in summer, but that also could be simmered gently in a tomato sauce for 15 minutes to make a quick meal — this way, sausages don’t have to be grilled/fried first.Summer bangers: The top 8 meaty sausages

More From The Irish Examiner