Donohoe: Supreme Court referral would clarify issues on abortion bill

The country’s newest junior minister believes President Michael D Higgins should refer the contentious abortion legislation to the Supreme Court.

Paschal Donohoe said the move would clarify any issues relating to the bill’s compliance with the constitution.

The Dublin Central TD was appointed Minister of State for European Affairs after Fine Gael colleague Lucinda Creighton voted against the Government and resigned from the post.

The contentious legislation, which for the first time will allow abortion in limited circumstances, was passed in the Dáil shortly after midnight. It will go to the Seanad next week – where it will be passed – and brought to President Higgins who will sign off on it and enshrine it into Irish law

Mr Donohoe said if the Supreme Court made a ruling on the legislation, like on the banking system, objectors’ concerns would be settled.

“One of the issues that has infused this debate is this question regarding the exact constitutionality of this bill and I do believe that it is in the interests of all concerned that that should be precisely answered,” said Mr Donohoe.

“I would welcome a speedy adjudication on that.”

The Government expects the law to be enacted before the Dáil breaks for summer on Thursday.

The landmark act, which enshrines a woman’s right to a termination if her life is at risk, including from suicide, was supported by the vast majority of the country’s politicians.

Five TDs, including Ms Creighton, were expelled from Fine Gael over their failure to vote for the bill. Peadar Toibin has also been suspended from Sinn Fein for six months for not supporting the bill.

Fine Gael party chairman Charlie Flanagan said the loss of members was regrettable but that they had to face the consequences of going against the rules.

“It was always going to be difficult because our party, being the largest government party, is reflective of public opinion and that public opinion is somewhat divided,” he said.

“It’s sad that people lose their association with our parliamentary party.

“Their views were sincere, their views were very stoutly held.

“I didn’t agree wit them but I recognise the fact there were differing views.”


Related Articles

Government will not immediately address pension problems seeing many lose €1,500 a year

Minister hits out at FF as government face Dáil defeat on pension anomaly affecting 40,000

No discrimination in Government proposal to auto-enrol all workers in pension plan, says Doherty

Mandatory retirement age may be abolished

More in this Section

Woman dies in Tipperary road accident

Drivers warned to be on alert for black ice

Dublin Rape Crisis Centre launches 16-day campaign

DUP leader Arlene Foster to reflect on rollercoaster year at party conference


Today's Stories

Election Crisis: 1992 winter election gave way to a Spring Tide

Call to speed up plans for fetal abnormality scans

Jack, 15, invents 'tractor safe lock' after grandad's farm accident

Election Crisis: Snap election may benefit Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael

Lifestyle

Having fled the Nazis, Elizabeth Friedlander created her own typeface before moving to Kinsale

On the double: Jennifer Zamparelli and balancing a hectic life and baby number two

Trim back for the festivities with these Christmas fitness tips

The 40-year-old charity that ensures no-one dies alone and poor

More From The Irish Examiner