Cabinet reviewing four options on abortion decisions

The Government could explore four separate options on new abortion laws, including one in which responsibility for decisions could be taken by the Medical Council.

In light of the tragic death of Savita Halappanavar in Galway and a global focus on Ireland’s abortion laws in the aftermath of the case, senior members of Government are now reviewing recommendations made in a report by the expert group, which was convened in light of the ABC case.

The death of Ms Halappanavar has brought the issue into sharp focus and has raised the possibility of differences within government — and Fine Gael — on how to proceed.

One option would be to delegate powers to the Medical Council and the HSE, thereby avoiding the need for primary legislation. This would mean that any decision would be taken on purely medical grounds and in consultation with the patient.

In cases where a woman was refused a termination she could appeal that decision to a panel of experts.

Another possibility is the selection of designated hospitals where terminations could be carried out, while an option also being considered is having two senior doctors signing off on an abortion.

It was reported yesterday that in cases where a woman claims to be suicidal, a psychiatrist would be required to carry out an assessment with the woman being able to use the appeals process in the event of her request being turned down.

Labour has said it wants to legislate on the X case, which would mean primary legislation would be needed.

There are differences of opinion within Fine Gael on the issue of abortion, prompting speculation that any way of avoiding the need for primary legislation — such as passing the issue over to the Medical Council — might be actively considered.

However, there are also doubts over whether that option, requiring secondary legislation, might be open to a legal challenge.

Ireland has until Nov 30 to respond to the European Court of Human Rights’ (ECHR) ruling on the ABC case which prompted the formation of the expert group and which was itself critical of Ireland’s current laws relating to abortion.

The report by the expert group, which is chaired by Mr Justice Seán Ryan, has only recently been made available to some senior members of the Government but is expected to be brought to Cabinet on Tuesday week.

© Irish Examiner Ltd. All rights reserved

More in this Section

Enda Kenny warns nurses that strike ‘will not help anyone’

Expert says Garda unit to tackle online terrorist radicalisation and recruitment would be useful

Bank inquiry forced to dump key sections to get report out before general election

Cork man, 25, charged with mum’s murder

You might also like

Breaking Stories

IFA to elect new president after 17-hour meeting overnight

Irish Water set to confirm plans to use River Shannon to deal with Dublin shortages

Poll shows rise in support for Fine Gael as Labour slump continues


A question of taste - Cónal Creedon

The first female priest ordained in Ireland discusses the influence of women priests in the Anglican ministry

Get to know all the facts if buying someone a drone for Christmas

Gay Byrne was a canny operator who allowed women be heard

More From The Irish Examiner