High Court orders new inquest into death of male cosmetic-surgery patient
Thursday, May 20, 2010 - 07:01 PM
The High Court has ruled that a fresh inquest be held into the death of a Dublin man who died while undergoing cosmetic surgery in Colombia.
In a judgement today, the President of the High Court Mr Justice Nicholas Kearns quashed the open verdict returned at the inquest into Pierre Christian Lawlor's death, and ordered that a new inquest take place.
The judge said that Dublin County Coroner Dr Kieran Geraghty should have agreed to Mr Lawlor's family's request to adjourn the July 2008 inquest into his death given the "unusual and tragic" circumstances involved. The adjournment had been sought to see if medical notes from Columbia could be obtained.
Mr Lawlor (aged 33,) of Belarmine Place, Stepaside, but originally from Lucan Co Dublin, died on September 3, 2007 at the Centro Colomblade Cirugia Plastica in Bogota, Colombia, while undergoing plastic surgery on his face and torso.
He was holidaying in Colombia with his wife Andrea Galleana (aged 26) and their young son Zachary, when he arranged to undergo the operation. His wife claimed that Christian consumed cocaine and alcohol in the days prior to undergoing the procedures, despite being told by the clinic not to take such substances 48 hours before surgery.
An inquest into his death was held in July 2008 which returned an open verdict.
However Mr Lawlor's family's argued that the inquest was flawed because the coroner refused to adjourn it due to the absence at that time of the Colombian clinic's medical notes, which they claim were vital in order to determin the cause of death, concerning Christian.
Christian's parents Tom and Margaret Lawlor, sought orders quashing Dublin County Coroner Dr Kieran Geraghty's decision of July 1, 2008 to refuse to adjourn the inquest.
They claimed the coroner was wrong to refuse the adjournment because medical notes from the clinic were the surgery were not available to experts including the State Pathologist Dr Marie Cassidy. Those notes were made available a month later.
Dr Geraghty opposed the application, and claimed that at all times he acted properly and judicially. He claimed that the notes would not have made a difference and that after making inquiries was informed that the medical notes would not be available for the inquest.
In his judgement Mr Justice Kearns said that the refusal to grant the adjournment was disproportionate and and inappropriate and that there was no overwhelming need to conclude the inquest forthwith. The judge said that this was a highly unusual case which raised matters that caused great distress to the Lawlor family.
The judge said that the Lawlor family had raised legitimate concerns and were in his view deprived of the opportunity of a meaningful participation in the inquest because of then non-availablilty of the hospital records.
He added that the coroner's refusal to grant the adjournment was based on the belief that clinic's notes could not have been obtained unless criminal proceedings were contemplated. This was not the case as the notes became available shortly after the inquest took place.
However Dr Geraghty, the judge added, should have adjourned the inquest to allow a reasonable opportunity to obtain those records and have them examined by a medical expert.
Irish Examiner live news app for smartphones lets you quickly access breaking news, sport, business, entertainment and weather.
Irish Examiner ePaper app gives you the entire newspaper delivered to your phone or tablet for as little as 55c a day.
A man who appeared to provide sign language interpretation on stage for Nelson Mandela's memorial service, attended by scores of heads of state, was a "fake", the national director of the Deaf Federation of South Africa said.
The troika is leaving Ireland with business unfinished, including changes to the medical and legal service, but they will be pursued through the new EU governance to which all eurozone countries are now subject.
The ECB could be forced to introduce another long- term refinancing operation and drag the deposit rate into a negative territory to cushion the region from another year of sluggish growth and the uncertainty caused by the comprehensive assessment of the banks, according to the Bank of America Merrill Lynch 2014 economic outlook.
IT'S one of the most iconic features on the Cork skyline. First established as a monastic site in 606 AD, St Fin Barre's Cathedral now houses a French neo-gothic cathedral designed in 1862 by William Burges of London.
Tipperary native Brian Lonergan fulfilled a long-standing ambition when his tricolour appeared on live TV during Sunday's NFL clash between the San Francisco 49ers and the Seattle Seahawks at Candlestick Park.
THE scandal at the Central Remedial Clinic is a gift to the Government. Here we have an organisation seemingly plundering charitable funds, to feather the nests of a group of Fianna Fáil insiders, all of whom can be linked easily to former Taoiseach Bertie Ahern.