Kildare man gets life for 'sad and outrageous death'
Friday, November 23, 2012 - 02:58 PM
A Kildare man who stabbed his ex-partner six times in the chest in what has been described as a “shocking, sad and outrageous death” by the presiding judge, has been handed a mandatory life sentence after he was found guilty by a jury at the Central Criminal Court.
Michael McDonald was also found guilty of assault causing harm to John Lawlor (aged 44) and is to be sentenced on this at a later date pending a victim impact report.
The jury returned a unanimous verdict of guilty on both counts after two hours and 41 minutes of deliberations. McDonald did not show any reaction when the verdicts were read out.
McDonald (aged 51) of Barnhill, Castledermot had pleaded not guilty to the murder of Ms Breda Cummins on May 13, 2010 at Michael Dooley Terrace, Athy. He had pleaded guilty on arraignment to the manslaughter of the mother-of-one but this plea was not accepted by the Director of Public Prosecutions. McDonald further pleaded not guilty to assault causing harm to John Lawlor (aged 44) of Pearse Terrace, Castledermot at the same address on the same date.
McDonald, who has been diagnosed with Alcohol Dependency Syndrome and Schitzoaffective Disorder by a clinical psychiatrist and had been prescribed anti-psychotic drugs at the age of 16, had previously been in a five-year relationship with Ms Cummins, who was also an alcoholic. He had told gardaí it was a "tempestous relationship," and that Ms Cummins started going out with Mr Lawlor several days after the break-up.
The 13-day trial heard that McDonald, who had been drinking alcohol on the evening of the murder and had taken sleeping tablets, had brought a kitchen knife from his home in Castledermot to Michael Dooley's Terrace to “rescue Breda” as he believed she wanted to return to his house.
He had phoned her 13 times that evening and called gardaí to check on her at around 11pm as he believed she was in danger.
McDonald told gardaí he thought Mr Lawlor “took advantage of her when she was vulnerable”.
McDonald arrived at the house at around midnight and asked to see Ms Cummins. Mr Lawlor and the house owner Michael Fennell were downstairs when Ms Cummins told McDonald to come upstairs, Mr Lawlor followed him to the bedroom.
A fight broke out between Mr Lawlor and McDonald and he was stabbed in the hand by McDonald with the kitchen knife.
After Mr Lawlor left the room to tend to his bleeding hand, McDonald turned to Ms Cummins and stabbed her six times in the chest with the kitchen knife and said, “I love you.”
“She was in fear of me. I lost the plot. I was in a rage. I said f*ck you bitch, you messed up my life,” he said in a garda interview the following day.
He said Ms Cummins was looking at him as he stabbed her and her last word was 'Michael.'
McDonald initially lied to gardaí that he did not bring a knife to the house as he thought the gardaí would think he went with the intention of stabbing someone. He said he had been carrying a knife around with him for a while after he claimed he was attacked in Dublin with Stanley knives several months prior to the stabbings.
McDonald told gardaí he “lost the plot” and it was not his intention to kill anyone. He said he felt betrayed that Ms Cummins had taken Mr Lawlor's side in the row.
He told gardaí Ms Cummins would wind him up with phone calls, screaming 'Rescue me, rescue me,'. “I think it was a game to her,” he said.
McDonald initially told gardaí he had thought he had only only stabbed Ms Cummins in the arm and had not intended to kill her but described the stabbing as a “frenzy stabbing, striking her in the heart.”
“I didn't mean to kill that girl. I liked her. I have killed the girl and I f*cked up my life now,” he admitted to gardaí.
Evidence was also given in the trial that McDonald went to Martin Byrne's house shortly afterwards and admitted the stabbings, blessed himself in front of a picture of the Sacred Heart and said a prayer, asking God for forgiveness.
Mr Byrne told the jury he did not believe McDonald had stabbed anyone because there was no blood on his clothes and he “seemed ok.”
McDonald had left the kitchen knife stuck in the ground of another friend, Ms Martina Hickey's garden after he left the house at Michael Dooley Terrace.
Clinical psychiatrist Dr Alan Byrne gave evidence that he had examined McDonald on a number of occasions when he admitted himself to the psychiatric unit at Naas General Hospital between 1998 and 2006 where he reported psychotic symptoms in the 51-year-old.
Dr Byrne said psychotic symptoms, which Mr McDonald had displayed at times when he examined him, such as believing he had magical powers to prevent the American and British armies invading Iraq and that the Devil had left messages on his voice mail to kill himself, are extremely rare in alcoholics and that McDonald had a mental illness.
Ms June Cummins (aged 32), a sister of Breda said, after the sentencing of McDonald, that her whole family still cannot believe Breda had died “in such a cruel way.”
Ms Cummins, who was the last of her family members to see Breda the day before her death, said Breda had a "good heart" and Breda's last words to her were “I love you sis” and Breda had given her a hug.
Ms Cummins said Breda's death has affected deeply their mother Barbara, brothers John, Kenny and Jason and sisters Johanna, Sabrina and Pamela along with Breda's 15-year-old son. The Cummins lost their sister Hazel in 2002 through natural causes. Family members wore t-shirts bearing Breda's photograph and on the back displayed Breda's birth date and death date.
“Breda's death caused us a lot of heartache and we will never forget her. Breda was a loving, caring person and had a great heart and didn't deserve what happened to her. We are delighted now we have got justice for my sister's death. She can rest in peace now with our other sister Hazel,” said Ms Cummins.
Defence counsel Mr Feargal Kavanagh, SC, with instructing solicitor Sean Brown, in his closing speech, described the case as a “tragic case” as McDonald had been allowed to “fall through the cracks” of the health service system despite his numerous cries for help over the years.
“He was never involuntarily committed when he went for help and discharged himself several times and didn't get the treatment he required,” said Mr Kavanagh.
Ms Justice O'Malley thanked the jury for their care and attention in what she said was "a sad case to listen to" and excused them from jury duty for seven years.
Irish Examiner live news app for smartphones lets you quickly access breaking news, sport, business, entertainment and weather.
Irish Examiner ePaper app gives you the entire newspaper delivered to your phone or tablet for as little as 55c a day.
PREMIER LEAGUE:Southampton v Man CityManchester City boss Manuel Pellegrini has reiterated how highly he rates Sergio Aguero, emphasising that he regards the Argentina international as a better all-round player than Luis Suarez.
South Africans united in mourning for Nelson Mandela yesterday, but while some celebrated his remarkable life with dance and song, others fretted that the anti-apartheid hero's death would make the nation vulnerable again to racial and social tensions.
HEINEKEN CUP POOL SIX:Munster v PerpignanMunster will go in to their must-win Heineken Cup clash with Pool 1 leaders Perpignan tomorrow intending to meet fire with fire against a powerful French Top 14 side at Thomond Park.
The grandmother of a toddler with Down's syndrome has been waiting a year for a response from the Taoiseach and three government ministers to correspondence about disability cuts referred to them on her behalf by the troika.