Don't appoint civilian to Garda Commissioner job, warns security expert

A prominent security expert has warned that a civilian should not be appointed the new Garda Commissioner.

It had been suggested someone from outside the force would make the best replacement after Nóirín O'Sullivan's shock retirement on Sunday night.

Ms O'Sullivan had been in charge during several controversies including those over inflated breath test statistics and penalty points.

But former deputy director of military intelligence Michael Murphy said the role is too large for someone outside the Gardaí.

He said: "If one of the functions (of the Commissioner's job) is in intelligence and responsibility for the security of the state, and the other in policing then you have to ask yourself why would you put in a civilian in a function that they probably have no background whatsoever in."

meanwhile, there have been a number of call for Ms O'Sullivan's replacement to come from outside Ireland.

Former Northern Ireland Policing Ombudsman, Nuala O’Loan, led those calls.

Ms O’Loan said Ms O’Sullivan’s departure seemed “almost inevitable” because of the serious issues that had come to light during her time at the helm of the force.

“Given the extent of the problems within An Garda Síochána, somebody coming in from outside would have a better opportunity of doing the job,” she told RTÉ.

She added: “They need somebody who has extensive experience, who has experience of change and who has the determination to bring about change.”


Related Articles

Mark Toland begins tenure as chief of Garda Inspectorate

Former Garda Commissioner Nóirín O'Sullivan joins nonprofit policing advocacy group

If An Garda Síochána was a chain of hotels you'd shut it down, says former Ombudsman

Policing Authority will decide on next Garda Commissioner: Donohoe

More in this Section

American doctor found not guilty of sexually assaulting Cork patient

184 people sleep rough in Dublin on November 7 - highest number since records began

Accused looked like a 'monster' says woman who claims she was sexually assaulted by Tinder date

IBRC to seek court orders requiring members of Quinn family to set out relationship with new venture


Today's Stories

Questions still need to be answered in Maurice McCabe email controversy

Mixed reaction to State’s €30m loan to An Post

Nursing initiative to boost services

Golden rules for online shopping safety

Lifestyle

Toy story: 10 toys guaranteed to bring out the kid in all of us

GameTech: Star Wars Battlefront II: Chance to win Loot Skywalker

Military top brass: Meet the conductor of the army’s Southern Brigade band

Album review: Experience counts on U2’s return to form

More From The Irish Examiner