Rare victory for rape victim’s mother in compensation bid

A woman who became a symbol for the groundswell of opposition to China’s labour camp system scored a rare victory in an appeal for compensation in a case that generated a huge public outcry.

The Hunan Provincial People’s High Court ruled in favour of Tang Hui, who last year was sentenced to 18 months in a labour camp for petitioning for harsher penalties for the men who abducted, raped and prostituted her 11-year-old daughter.

At the time, Tang’s case drew massive public opposition and she was released within days.

The labour camp — or “re-education through labour” — system was established to punish early critics of the Communist Party, but now is used by local officials to deal with people challenging their authority on issues including land rights and corruption.

Cases like Tang’s last year have galvanised critics, many of them within the government, and public expectations for reform have grown.

In January, Tang sued the labour commission of the city of Yongzhou for an apology and compensation, but the lawsuit was rejected four months later. She then appealed to the provincial court.

Yesterday, the court ordered the labour commission to pay Tang 2,941 yuan (€366) for violating her personal freedom and causing mental damage, Tang’s lawyers said.

Tang could not immediately be reached for comment as calls to her mobile phone rang unanswered. One of her lawyers, Xu Liping, said Tang has accepted the ruling and that to a large extent, it offered comfort to her.

“To Tang Hui, this is a relatively big turning point for her. Now she can start to regain a normal life,” Xu said.

Tang’s other lawyer, Pu Zhiqiang, said the lawsuit’s significance was limited because it was focused on obtaining compensation rather than questioning the legality of the labour camp sentence she had been given.

“The court ruling is a result of a compromise between the various forces that are exerting influence over the case.

“Of course, it’s not as though real justice or fairness has been achieved,” Pu said.

Pu said Tang had been pressured by local authorities not to file an appeal against the labour camp sentence itself and so her only avenue for redress later was to seek financial compensation.

“From the perspective of compensation, this ruling has been based on evidence and should be welcomed,” Pu said.

“I personally feel that the court has done to the greatest extent what it can do under the present circumstances.”

The ruling also came across as the court’s tacit acknowledgment that Tang’s case was particularly egregious, said Zhang Ming, a China politics professor at Renmin University.

“For people like Tang Hui, it is totally unfair. Her daughter had been through a horrible experience, and you send her to labour camp? It can’t be justified,” Zhang said.

The court, however, ruled that Tang’s request for a written apology from the Yongzhou labour commission could not be granted because there was no legal basis for it.

This could be a strategy for the authorities to avoid acknowledging wrongdoing, Zhang said. “Even if the labour committee lost this lawsuit, it doesn’t mean they’re admitting that they were wrong,” he said.


On June 26, we sat outside the first bar to open here since lockdown began on March 15. There are only two bars in the valley. Cafes serve drinks, but these are bar-bars, the kind that stay open after midnight.Damien Enright: Fruit trees are laden with their bounty as we prepare to leave

In October 1986, 52 mute swans, living peacefully on the Tolka in Dublin, were drenched in diesel oil accidentally released into the river. Swan-catchers went into action; only one bird died before they reached it.Richard Collins: Human crisis will offer chance for wild animal research

It's a typically Irish summer’s day of sunshine and occasional showers. Travel restrictions have been eased again and we venture forth to one of nature’s gems, Gougane Barra, deep in the mountains of West Cork.Donal Hickey: Gougane Barra has peace and wildness

When the ferryman pulls away from the pier and the salty spray of the sea hits your face the feeling of release from the mainland is deeply pleasurable. Your island awaits. Whether for a day trip or a holiday, the lure of the islands is as magnetic as ever.The Islands of Ireland: The lure of the less-visited

More From The Irish Examiner