Move policy debate to centre stage - Issues ignored in personality wars

THE Australian Svengali Lynton Crosby, who has led right-of-centre election campaigns around the world and is credited with David Cameron’s unexpected Commons majority two years ago, has contrived to reduce the British general election battle to one simple but excluding question: “Who do you want to lead Britain, Theresa May or Jeremy Corbyn? Personality rather than policy is the battleground.

Aided and abetted by a virulently biased media, that play-the-man-not-the-ball policy reaped early rewards. However, a weekend poll suggests the British electorate, so grievously puppeteered on Brexit, may have smelt a rat. The Conservatives’ lead over Labour has fallen to single figures. May’s Tories are on 44%, down 5%. Corbyn’s Labour is supported by 35%, up by 4%. May’s march toward absolute power may not be as easy as she anticipated when she cast aside all assurances that she would not call an election. Her change of heart, or power grab if you prefer, came about because polls, those fickle weather vanes, promised her a parliamentary majority that hardly seems healthy in an inclusive democracy. If the gap is any narrower than 44/35 on election day, then Britain faces cultural division on a par with Trump’s America. This would further debase democracy and exacerbate the disenchanted detachment demagogues depend on to secure power.

The personality-rather-than-policy principle is also the defining characteristic of the race between Simon Coveney and Leo Varadkar to succeed Enda Kenny. The face-on-the-poster imperative dominates. The candidates’ policy differences — if there are any of substance — are irrelevant. All arguments are framed as if the prospects either candidate might offer Fine Gael, or the career opportunities they could offer Oireachtas colleagues, are the only issues. If either contender was to suggest anything as challenging, or as relevant, as Declan Costello’s long-forgotten call for social justice, Towards a Just Society, their respective Lynton Crosbys would be apocalyptic. Why introduce principle into a competition that seems more like Ladies Day at Killarney Races than a test of political imagination or intent? Why offer hostages to fortune when charisma is the defining issue?

As the fates often decree, this week may offer an opportunity for the candidates to show their true colours — if their Lynton Crosbys are not asleep. The sale of a quarter of the State stake in AIB may be announced. This will generate significant revenue. But what to do with that money? Will it, as those who see Ireland more as an economy than a society advocate, be used to pay down debt? Or might it be used, say, to rebuild the National Pension Reserve? Establishing that pot was progressive — take a bow Charlie McCreevy — but it was plundered to ruin to bail out rotten banks, so it seems reasonable to suggest that the revenue generated by the sale of a rejuvenated bank should be used to rebuild it — especially as the banks’ recklessness destroyed so many pension schemes.

How the candidates might answer that question would tell us all we need to know about them but probably more than they would like us to know. Sadly, there is a better chance of a Corbyn victory than a direct answer. Mushrooms, dark, etc.

More on this topic

British police ’formally considering’ allegations Tories broke law due to call centre use British police ’formally considering’ allegations Tories broke law due to call centre use

UK government's 'shabby deal' with DUP branded a threat to Good Friday AgreementUK government's 'shabby deal' with DUP branded a threat to Good Friday Agreement

Everything you need to know about the Conservative-DUP dealEverything you need to know about the Conservative-DUP deal

Theresa May has bought herself time but she remains on probation, warns Tory MPTheresa May has bought herself time but she remains on probation, warns Tory MP


Cupid must be something of a motoring enthusiast, as he had most definitely steered his way in the neighbourhood when Amie Gould and Shane O’Neill met at the Rally of the Lakes 12 years ago.Wedding of the Week: Cupid steers couple to right track

When it comes to podcasting, all it takes is one idea — and who knows where it can take you.Podcast Corner: Crimes and creatures rule at Cork’s first podcast fest

Claymation meets science fiction in this enchanting film, writes Esther McCarthy.Latest Shaun adventure is out of this world

After breaking through as a character with mental health issues in her hit TV series, Irish actress Aisling Bea is happy to take another step to stardom in a new Netflix comedy with Paul Rudd, writes Ed Power.Aisling Bea and Paul Rudd team up for new comedy

More From The Irish Examiner